Technology and Constitutional Rot

JB

I have posted a draft of my latest article, Technology and Constitutional Rot, on SSRN. Here is the abstract:

Technological change affects the Constitution not only by creating new problems of constitutional interpretation, but also by changing the distribution of economic and political power. New technologies alter what governments and private actors can know, control, predict, and accomplish. When constitutional institutions fail to adapt, large shifts in power and control can lead to constitutional rot: the process by which a democratic republic becomes less democratic and less republican over time. The United States has suffered from increasing constitutional rot over the past four decades; rapid technological change has made the rot worse.

Our Second Gilded Age has many similarities to the technological and economic upheavals of the First Gilded Age, which was also a period of constitutional decay. We now live in the Algorithmic Society, where public and private decision making increasingly depend on algorithms, artificial intelligence, platforms, large-scale data collection and digital surveillance. The Algorithmic Society produces an Algorithmic State, including a National Surveillance State organized around prediction and prevention. These changes disproportionately strengthen the executive branch, weaken Congress, limit practical judicial oversight, and increase government’s dependence on powerful private firms and privately-owned technological infrastructure.

Large global technology companies increasingly exercise governing power over communications, commerce, national security, access to information, and public debate. As a result, government and technology firms engage in repeated attempts at mutual co-optation, blurring traditional distinctions between public and private power. Digital platforms reshape the public sphere through an attention economy that weakens knowledge, intensifies political polarization, and erodes trust. These changes exacerbate four central features of constitutional rot: growing wealth inequality, political polarization, loss of trust, and policy disasters.

Despite these dire circumstances, the United States has recovered from periods of constitutional rot before. The First Gilded Age gave way to the reforms of the Progressive Era and the New Deal. Today constitutional renewal involves a different set of reforms: new digital privacy laws and new antitrust, civil-rights, and due-process protections. Renewal means reconstructing and improving the knowledge institutions that underwrite our democracy. It requires structural changes that better allow Congress to check and oversee the executive branch. And it requires reforms that secure and strengthen our system of democratic representation.