Balkinization   |
Balkinization
Balkinization Symposiums: A Continuing List                                                                E-mail: Jack Balkin: jackbalkin at yahoo.com Bruce Ackerman bruce.ackerman at yale.edu Ian Ayres ian.ayres at yale.edu Corey Brettschneider corey_brettschneider at brown.edu Mary Dudziak mary.l.dudziak at emory.edu Joey Fishkin joey.fishkin at gmail.com Heather Gerken heather.gerken at yale.edu Abbe Gluck abbe.gluck at yale.edu Mark Graber mgraber at law.umaryland.edu Stephen Griffin sgriffin at tulane.edu Jonathan Hafetz jonathan.hafetz at shu.edu Jeremy Kessler jkessler at law.columbia.edu Andrew Koppelman akoppelman at law.northwestern.edu Marty Lederman msl46 at law.georgetown.edu Sanford Levinson slevinson at law.utexas.edu David Luban david.luban at gmail.com Gerard Magliocca gmaglioc at iupui.edu Jason Mazzone mazzonej at illinois.edu Linda McClain lmcclain at bu.edu John Mikhail mikhail at law.georgetown.edu Frank Pasquale pasquale.frank at gmail.com Nate Persily npersily at gmail.com Michael Stokes Paulsen michaelstokespaulsen at gmail.com Deborah Pearlstein dpearlst at yu.edu Rick Pildes rick.pildes at nyu.edu David Pozen dpozen at law.columbia.edu Richard Primus raprimus at umich.edu K. Sabeel Rahmansabeel.rahman at brooklaw.edu Alice Ristroph alice.ristroph at shu.edu Neil Siegel siegel at law.duke.edu David Super david.super at law.georgetown.edu Brian Tamanaha btamanaha at wulaw.wustl.edu Nelson Tebbe nelson.tebbe at brooklaw.edu Mark Tushnet mtushnet at law.harvard.edu Adam Winkler winkler at ucla.edu Compendium of posts on Hobby Lobby and related cases The Anti-Torture Memos: Balkinization Posts on Torture, Interrogation, Detention, War Powers, and OLC The Anti-Torture Memos (arranged by topic) Recent Posts David Brooks gets nostalgic for the 18th century
|
Friday, May 06, 2011
David Brooks gets nostalgic for the 18th century
Sandy Levinson
David Brooks continues to be perhaps the most vexing of the NYTimes's columnists. He is clearly smart and often quite interesting. But, with regularity, he writes columns whose flaws seem obvious. So consider his column in today's Times, in which he basically laments the collapse of the Federalist Party in the 1800 election. That is, he beleives that the United States is (or ought to be) a "republic," very definitely not a "democracy." (No doubt he would regard it as a strength of the United States Constitution that it is "undemocratic.") As Gordon Wood points out in his magisterial Oxford history of the United States between 1789-1815, the Federalists (like, for that matter, most of those who framed the Constitution) decidedly mistrusted the masses and wished for leadership by elites who could be counted on to identify and then to act on "the public interest" instead of crasser interests (such as the preferences of their unenlightened constituents, who were expected to defer to their betters rather than prefer officeholders who took constituents' views all that seriously).
Comments:
Nonsense. Elitism is alive and well. Why do you think you are the only one at Balkinization who takes comments from the peanut gallery? :)
But I would still rather hear your views on Garrett Epps' theory on the debt limit.
I'd have to agree with mls that elitism is very much the order of today's society. In fact, the real threat we face (IMHO) is from oligarchy, not an overabundance of democracy, much less meritocracy.
Mis,
I think that's the point (re elitism). David Brooks is, in my opinion, deeply divorced from the reality of our current society. However, so is the political and social elite of this country. That's why he gets prime real estate for his ramblings. The reality is that we have an oligarchy that is using democracy against "the rabble." Both parties are captured by the oligarchy and merely use democratic forms to retain power.
There were a few unseemly flaws in the country's founding; and the substrate dependence on elitist input is one such. I compare that sort of contradiction to something in law like the evidence rules for grand juries, which bodies have been known to incarcerate recalcitrant journalists.
It our time, the elites are meeting internet. Times are changing, slowly. Sometimes less slowly.
I agree that Brooks is indulging in fantasy, but I wonder why a law professor bothers to engage with newspaper columns when the same fantasy of elite rule is so pervasive in the legal academy. (Insert something about motes and planks.) In the academy, undemocratic sentiment usually takes the form of a belief that "basic human rights cannot be made subject to majority vote," i.e., abortion and gay marriage must be made legal by the courts, since the masses are too benighted to support these things by themselves.
As Prof. Levinson notes, judicial decisions of this nature don't attain much legitimacy in our current culture.
Jack Rakove's "Original Meanings - Politics and Ideas in the Making of the Constitution" includes Chapter VII "Federalism" and Chapter VIII "The Mirror of Representation" that David Brooks might not have read or understood in writing his column as there was no uniformity on republicanism on the part of the Framers/Founders, even among Federalists.
When I read a column like Brooks', I think of C. Wright Mills' "The Power Elite." I wonder what Mills would say about the current financial/economic situation with Republicans uninterested in reform that just might protect consumers from the excesses laid upon us in the 2008 Bush/Cheney Great Recession. As for Brooks, it should be kept in mind that his career as a pundit resulted from his criticism of Bill Buckley, as a result of which Brooks was hired by Buckley, didn't change Buckley's thinking, but his own. Hmm. Making lemonade?
Paul Krugman's column in today's NYTimes (5/9/11) "The Unwisdom of Elites" does not mention David Brooks and the latter's column that is the subject of this post. But those of us who follow Krugman's blog at the NYTimes are aware that he is not reluctant to criticize his fellow columnist by name.
Brooks' column can be summed up by two famous quotes:
“When the people find that they can vote themselves money, that will herald the end of the republic.” - Ben Franklin “The problem with socialism is that you eventually run out of other people’s money.” - Maggie Thatcher
The portion of Maggie's quote " ... other people' money ... " brings to mind Louis Brandeis' "Other People's Money and What Bankers Do With It" thinking back to the 2008 Bush/Cheney Great Recession. Paul Krugman in his NYTimes column yesterday "The Unwisdom of Elites" points to the fault of the elites rather than the masses. Keith Olberman' "Lotto Nation" yesterday points to why many of the poor are sucked into approving tax and other policies that are against their interests.
So I rather doubt that our yodeler's "marriage of Ben and Maggie" quotes sums up David Brooks' column. Ben was said to be sort of a womanizer, but I doubt that Maggie would have earned a second look from him.
I'm not sure what it is about Tea Partiers that makes them go around repeating fictional quotes from the Founding Fathers.
Kudos for having the guts to quote good old Karl Marx! Where he's right, he's right! Pity that that (being right) was comparatively rare with Karl & Friedrich!
What the concept of elites and enlightened republicanism misunderstands is that conflict in society is the rule - and not the exception. Incidentally, that's where I differ from Marx: He thought once the proletariat ruled, conflict would cease to exist. There is no one best solution the enlightened only are empowered to detect. The peaceful resolution of such conflicts between warring factions is the constant challenge of a community that is to thrive, and doing so by democratic means to me is the only viable way of communal life. However, democracy doesn't mean the "tyrrany of the majority" under all circumstances. You must excuse me for ceding to the enlightened courts the role of protecting unalienable minority and individual rights.
HD kaliteli porno izle ve boşal.
Post a Comment
Bayan porno izleme sitesi. Bedava ve ücretsiz porno izle size gelsin. Liseli kızların Bedava Porno ve Türbanlı ateşli hatunların sikiş filmlerini izle. Siyah karanlık odada porno yapan evli çift. harika Duvar Kağıtları bunlar tamamen ithal duvar kağıdı olanlar var
|
Books by Balkinization Bloggers Linda C. McClain and Aziza Ahmed, The Routledge Companion to Gender and COVID-19 (Routledge, 2024) David Pozen, The Constitution of the War on Drugs (Oxford University Press, 2024) Jack M. Balkin, Memory and Authority: The Uses of History in Constitutional Interpretation (Yale University Press, 2024) Mark A. Graber, Punish Treason, Reward Loyalty: The Forgotten Goals of Constitutional Reform after the Civil War (University of Kansas Press, 2023) Jack M. Balkin, What Roe v. Wade Should Have Said: The Nation's Top Legal Experts Rewrite America's Most Controversial Decision - Revised Edition (NYU Press, 2023) Andrew Koppelman, Burning Down the House: How Libertarian Philosophy Was Corrupted by Delusion and Greed (St. Martin’s Press, 2022) Gerard N. Magliocca, Washington's Heir: The Life of Justice Bushrod Washington (Oxford University Press, 2022) Joseph Fishkin and William E. Forbath, The Anti-Oligarchy Constitution: Reconstructing the Economic Foundations of American Democracy (Harvard University Press, 2022) Mark Tushnet and Bojan Bugaric, Power to the People: Constitutionalism in the Age of Populism (Oxford University Press 2021). Mark Philip Bradley and Mary L. Dudziak, eds., Making the Forever War: Marilyn B. Young on the Culture and Politics of American Militarism Culture and Politics in the Cold War and Beyond (University of Massachusetts Press, 2021). Jack M. Balkin, What Obergefell v. Hodges Should Have Said: The Nation's Top Legal Experts Rewrite America's Same-Sex Marriage Decision (Yale University Press, 2020) Frank Pasquale, New Laws of Robotics: Defending Human Expertise in the Age of AI (Belknap Press, 2020) Jack M. Balkin, The Cycles of Constitutional Time (Oxford University Press, 2020) Mark Tushnet, Taking Back the Constitution: Activist Judges and the Next Age of American Law (Yale University Press 2020). Andrew Koppelman, Gay Rights vs. Religious Liberty?: The Unnecessary Conflict (Oxford University Press, 2020) Ezekiel J Emanuel and Abbe R. Gluck, The Trillion Dollar Revolution: How the Affordable Care Act Transformed Politics, Law, and Health Care in America (PublicAffairs, 2020) Linda C. McClain, Who's the Bigot?: Learning from Conflicts over Marriage and Civil Rights Law (Oxford University Press, 2020) Sanford Levinson and Jack M. Balkin, Democracy and Dysfunction (University of Chicago Press, 2019) Sanford Levinson, Written in Stone: Public Monuments in Changing Societies (Duke University Press 2018) Mark A. Graber, Sanford Levinson, and Mark Tushnet, eds., Constitutional Democracy in Crisis? (Oxford University Press 2018) Gerard Magliocca, The Heart of the Constitution: How the Bill of Rights became the Bill of Rights (Oxford University Press, 2018) Cynthia Levinson and Sanford Levinson, Fault Lines in the Constitution: The Framers, Their Fights, and the Flaws that Affect Us Today (Peachtree Publishers, 2017) Brian Z. Tamanaha, A Realistic Theory of Law (Cambridge University Press 2017) Sanford Levinson, Nullification and Secession in Modern Constitutional Thought (University Press of Kansas 2016) Sanford Levinson, An Argument Open to All: Reading The Federalist in the 21st Century (Yale University Press 2015) Stephen M. Griffin, Broken Trust: Dysfunctional Government and Constitutional Reform (University Press of Kansas, 2015) Frank Pasquale, The Black Box Society: The Secret Algorithms That Control Money and Information (Harvard University Press, 2015) Bruce Ackerman, We the People, Volume 3: The Civil Rights Revolution (Harvard University Press, 2014) Balkinization Symposium on We the People, Volume 3: The Civil Rights Revolution Joseph Fishkin, Bottlenecks: A New Theory of Equal Opportunity (Oxford University Press, 2014) Mark A. Graber, A New Introduction to American Constitutionalism (Oxford University Press, 2013) John Mikhail, Elements of Moral Cognition: Rawls' Linguistic Analogy and the Cognitive Science of Moral and Legal Judgment (Cambridge University Press, 2013) Gerard N. Magliocca, American Founding Son: John Bingham and the Invention of the Fourteenth Amendment (New York University Press, 2013) Stephen M. Griffin, Long Wars and the Constitution (Harvard University Press, 2013) Andrew Koppelman, The Tough Luck Constitution and the Assault on Health Care Reform (Oxford University Press, 2013) James E. Fleming and Linda C. McClain, Ordered Liberty: Rights, Responsibilities, and Virtues (Harvard University Press, 2013) Balkinization Symposium on Ordered Liberty: Rights, Responsibilities, and Virtues Andrew Koppelman, Defending American Religious Neutrality (Harvard University Press, 2013) Brian Z. Tamanaha, Failing Law Schools (University of Chicago Press, 2012) Sanford Levinson, Framed: America's 51 Constitutions and the Crisis of Governance (Oxford University Press, 2012) Linda C. McClain and Joanna L. Grossman, Gender Equality: Dimensions of Women's Equal Citizenship (Cambridge University Press, 2012) Mary Dudziak, War Time: An Idea, Its History, Its Consequences (Oxford University Press, 2012) Jack M. Balkin, Living Originalism (Harvard University Press, 2011) Jason Mazzone, Copyfraud and Other Abuses of Intellectual Property Law (Stanford University Press, 2011) Richard W. Garnett and Andrew Koppelman, First Amendment Stories, (Foundation Press 2011) Jack M. Balkin, Constitutional Redemption: Political Faith in an Unjust World (Harvard University Press, 2011) Gerard Magliocca, The Tragedy of William Jennings Bryan: Constitutional Law and the Politics of Backlash (Yale University Press, 2011) Bernard Harcourt, The Illusion of Free Markets: Punishment and the Myth of Natural Order (Harvard University Press, 2010) Bruce Ackerman, The Decline and Fall of the American Republic (Harvard University Press, 2010) Balkinization Symposium on The Decline and Fall of the American Republic Ian Ayres. Carrots and Sticks: Unlock the Power of Incentives to Get Things Done (Bantam Books, 2010) Mark Tushnet, Why the Constitution Matters (Yale University Press 2010) Ian Ayres and Barry Nalebuff: Lifecycle Investing: A New, Safe, and Audacious Way to Improve the Performance of Your Retirement Portfolio (Basic Books, 2010) Jack M. Balkin, The Laws of Change: I Ching and the Philosophy of Life (2d Edition, Sybil Creek Press 2009) Brian Z. Tamanaha, Beyond the Formalist-Realist Divide: The Role of Politics in Judging (Princeton University Press 2009) Andrew Koppelman and Tobias Barrington Wolff, A Right to Discriminate?: How the Case of Boy Scouts of America v. James Dale Warped the Law of Free Association (Yale University Press 2009) Jack M. Balkin and Reva B. Siegel, The Constitution in 2020 (Oxford University Press 2009) Heather K. Gerken, The Democracy Index: Why Our Election System Is Failing and How to Fix It (Princeton University Press 2009) Mary Dudziak, Exporting American Dreams: Thurgood Marshall's African Journey (Oxford University Press 2008) David Luban, Legal Ethics and Human Dignity (Cambridge Univ. Press 2007) Ian Ayres, Super Crunchers: Why Thinking-By-Numbers is the New Way to be Smart (Bantam 2007) Jack M. Balkin, James Grimmelmann, Eddan Katz, Nimrod Kozlovski, Shlomit Wagman and Tal Zarsky, eds., Cybercrime: Digital Cops in a Networked Environment (N.Y.U. Press 2007) Jack M. Balkin and Beth Simone Noveck, The State of Play: Law, Games, and Virtual Worlds (N.Y.U. Press 2006) Andrew Koppelman, Same Sex, Different States: When Same-Sex Marriages Cross State Lines (Yale University Press 2006) Brian Tamanaha, Law as a Means to an End (Cambridge University Press 2006) Sanford Levinson, Our Undemocratic Constitution (Oxford University Press 2006) Mark Graber, Dred Scott and the Problem of Constitutional Evil (Cambridge University Press 2006) Jack M. Balkin, ed., What Roe v. Wade Should Have Said (N.Y.U. Press 2005) Sanford Levinson, ed., Torture: A Collection (Oxford University Press 2004) Balkin.com homepage Bibliography Conlaw.net Cultural Software Writings Opeds The Information Society Project BrownvBoard.com Useful Links Syllabi and Exams |