Balkinization: Google Book Search Settlement

Comments:

Neil,

Thanks for reporting on this one. I'm of the opinion that it is only a matter of time before any digitized use is considered fair, if only on enforceability-cum-judicial-economy grounds. Sooner rather than later, if I had my way.

Am I correct that you would hav been happier with a vindication of the fair use defense?

# posted by

Robert Link : 10:12 PM

Thanks for your comment, Robert. I would have been happier with a successful fair use defense plus effective orphan works legislation. The successful fair use defense would have only allowed Google to display very short snippets of copyrighted books, not to make available the full text of out print books, as orphan works legislation could make possible. I'm skeptical that any digitized use will be deemed fair, and as I wrote in my main post, I think the Google settlement could make it more difficult for digital archives of books to qualify for fair use.

# posted by

Neil Netanel : 10:57 PM

When I say I expect all digitized uses to eventually be deemed fair, I'm talking very long term. But in the end, yes, I think judicial economy and enforceability will require such a finding. Not to mention that such a holding would actually be more in keeping with the patent and copyright clause per se. In the Gutenberg era there may have been call to grant these monopolies, but when reproduction and distribution become effectively limitless, well, as I've said elsewhere, when supply approaches infinity one reasonably expects price to approach the nadir. In the Gutenberg era, with attendant limits on replication and distribution, there were limits on supply. No longer. And that doesn't even factor in the burgeoning wealth of content creators of the current era.

Along similar lines, you might enjoy this post in the wake of the 2005 Grokster decision and Brian Martin's Againt Intellectual Property.
From "Disagreeing With My Betters":

"Where the public, and justice, and the Constitution, would best be served by a radical curtailment of copyright and patent durations and an equally radical strengthening of fair use doctrines, what we can expect, so long as there's so very much money to be made under the current outdated systems, is more of same."

Peace,

rl

# posted by

Robert Link : 11:08 PM

Sigh - My worries, when I heard about the settlement, were exactly those articulated in your post--it's not very comforting to have them confirmed by someone with expertise in these matters.

It really depressed the hell out of me. Nobody had a better chance than Google of fighting and winning this thing--especially with Patry as their copyright counsel. Now, it's that much harder for anyone else. Sigh!

# posted by

X.Trapnel : 11:30 PM

Preface: I am not a lawyer (IANAL) and only occasionally post rant response comments on this site.

***

"So in many ways the proposed settlement is a win-win-win-win (for Google, the copyright holders, the libraries, and the public)."

I'm not so certain that this is a "win" for the public. It depends on the future actions of Google and how it "serves" the public and the public interest. As we've so clearly seen recently, the interests of a mega-corporation and the public rarely coincide, and if they should happen to, can diverge at any point. (To segue, I think it would be more accurate to refer to the interests of the executives and directors of mega-corporations as compared to the rest of the world.)

And it's those interests, Google's and the public's, that have likely diverged markedly due to this settlement. As you've noted, Google now has a "de facto monopoly over this "universal library" service." That monopoly represents an asset that Google fought for, paid dearly for, and hopes to make a large profit from. Any events or interests that would in any way potentially diminish those expected profits would be viewed by Google as adversarial. That includes the interests of the public. If a law were to be passed requiring licensing of copyright, Google could easily lose its advantage in the online book reading and viewing market and so would likely devote great effort and resources to fight any such future law.

In other words, this settlement makes Google a likely ally of the publishing industry, not the public or the public's interests, if that was ever the case.

As I've noted, IANAL, and certainly not a high tier professor of law, but I was thinking about the MP3.com case, where MP3.com had made available (copyrighted by others) music for online listening. MP3.com was sued by the publishers and lost their case, to the "tune" of hundreds of millions of dollars - with no resulting market advantages whatsoever. From my unlearned view the main differences between the MP3.com case and this Google case is that MP3.com made available full songs rather than partial "samples" - (a possible "fair use") as Google has done in most cases with books. The other difference though is that MP3.com required prospective online listeners to provide proof that they had the original CDs containing the songs they wanted access to. Google makes no such requirement of book viewers. MP3.com basically tried to provide a world wide listening ability to music members of the public had paid for. At the time it was suggested that the error of MP3.com's ways was in that it, MP3.com, did the copying to the net of the music (which MP3.com also bought) rather than the individuals that had bought the CDs to be listened to. Again, supposedly, if MP3.com had made online space available for members to upload their own digital copies of their music, then the service would have been acceptable.

Obviously that's not true anymore and probably wasn't at the time but was simply suggested as a possible basis to find against MP3.com. At this point it's become clear that the rights of purchasers of copyrighted material or licenses thereof have very very little rights other than those specifically granted by the publishers. That apparently includes copying digital material onto other devices for backup or any reason, including overcoming the obsolescence of devices used for listening or viewing. We've seen something of that with "services" that provide music for download that are ended by publishers or their vendors, effectively making the music purchased no more than bits in the digital bit bucket. Taken to its extreme, copy "protecting" of works extended into the future will likely prevent in some or many cases those works ever becoming part of the public domain - the supposed tradeoff basis for copyright protection in the U.S. constitution.

Google is now an ally with these publishers. They've got their agreement. Any agreements that might be made with others would be a threat to expected profits and any laws that might provide greater rights to the public would be even more of a threat.

The publishers just got a very powerful and wealthy ally and the public lost one, or at least any pretext that it ever had one.

P.S. Thanks for your insights and concerns.

# posted by

Amos Anan : 6:42 AM

If you read the whole settlement agreement, you notice that it's pretty limited-- hardly an "iTunes for books" as people say.

First there is no downloading allowed, and no remote access except at big institutions. Public libraries get one terminal-- that's it-- and limited printing, for a FEE!

Even people who buy the books can't download them-- and can only print them in a limited fashion.

Google also says they will set up a registry for publc domain books, but they haven't yet, and are currently violating their agreements with the host libraries by not making all PD scans available.

All in all-- it's weak weak weak. No great research tool, as it has been hyped.

# posted by

semichorus : 4:24 AM

i don't see how you can possibly
say this is a "win" for the public,
not without knowing the _cost_
that will be charged for "access",
as well as the nature of the "access".

over and above their abandonment
of a robust defense of "fair use",
google capitulated in every way to
desires of the publishing industry,
and left the public holding the bag.

google gives 'em an income-stream
from "property" they'd abandoned,
and also gives 'em an infrastructure
to impose a rental model on books
-- one that the publishers could
_not_ have created on their own,
as evidenced by the music biz --
that means the public has to pay for
books that we can't even download.

not only that, but the prices for this
"rental" of books are quite obscene!
have you studied their fee schedule?

the market for e-books hasn't even
begun to form, let alone shake out,
yet already the publishers want to
freeze into place the parameters?
and google is going to assist them?
and raise the entry barrier as well?

no, no, a thousand times no!

this is no "win" for the public, and
it's no "win" for the future either...

you really need to go back to your
desk and study all this some more.

these books represent our culture!
we will not let someone seize them
and hold them for ransom. no sir!

-bowerbird

# posted by

bowerbird : 8:04 PM

Good points-- it would be understandable to have display only for subscription accounts, but for actual consumers to be put into a rental-only position when they BUY the book is unacceptable.

I still think that the days of free downloads for public domain works will soon end. Google is not going to keep that up for long. It's all gonna be rental as you say.

# posted by

Jim Carlile : 11:25 PM

I think the Google settlement could make it more difficult for digital archives of books to qualify for fair use.
Dissertation Writing | Essay Writing | Research Paper Writing

# posted by

Unknown : 7:27 AM

that doesn't even factor in the burgeoning wealth of content creators of the current era.
Term Paper Writing | Thesis Writing

# posted by

Unknown : 7:28 AM

The good thing about your information is that it is explicit enough for students to grasp. Thanks for your efforts in spreading academic knowledge.

logo design | design logo

# posted by

Dana Weber : 6:07 AM

Many institutions limit access to their online information. Making this information available will be an asset to all.

# posted by

Anonymous : 7:32 AM

Thanks for the information. I really enjoyed, I would like get more
information about this,because is very beautiful, thanks for sharing
Saç Ekimi

# posted by

Op Dr Ali Mezdeği : 5:59 AM

I had a great time reading your article and I found it interesting. This is such a beautiful topic that me and my friends are talking about. Thanks for this blog, we are enlightened.
Free classified Ads Pakistan -
Advertising Agencies In Pakistan

# posted by

amelia : 6:07 AM

Wow It is nice posting. I like it. Thanks a lOtAssignment Help

# posted by

Rajendra : 6:32 AM

Everyday Doggie Awful towards Cuboid bone Collarure it comfy. Of course it easy dog collar to change. And absolutely sure it includes nasty buckles for convenient launching. However , more than functionality, the training collar is barely ordinary cold. Your tv screen prints allow every body who exactly views them knowour doggy isn that they are weird with. Your woman along to strut the material if your lady intersected, the lady travelling to stop booty not to mention dog carrier just take bands.

?Charm Pink colored Collarow approximately planning made by hand? The following Ny city White collar will certainly charm the head with its glossy gallstones. Just the right dog leashes quantity jewelry.

# posted by

Unknown : 6:42 AM

Easily, the post is really the sweetest on this worthwhile topic. I fit in with your conclusions and will eagerly look forward to your approaching updates. Saying thanks will not just be sufficient, for the exceptional clarity in your writing. I will immediately grab your rss feed to stay privy of any updates.
Paket lulur susu domba asli
Crystal x jakarta
BB cream untuk kulit berminyak

# posted by

muhammad : 12:12 AM

Really nice and interesting post. I was looking for this kind of information and enjoyed reading this one. Keep posting. Thanks for sharing.
baju pilot anak, baju seragam tk, baju profesi anak

# posted by

Unknown : 11:53 AM

# posted by

Unknown : 10:04 AM

# posted by

Anonymous : 1:54 AM

obat herbal mengobati kanker serviks stadium 3
obat alami untuk mencegah kanker serviks
obat medis untuk kanker serviks
wwwobat kanker serviks
obat vaksin kanker serviks
obat untuk mengatasi kanker serviks
Tumbuhan untuk obat kanker serviks
Obat untuk menyembuhkan kanker serviks
obat untuk penderita kanker serviks
obat tradisional untuk kanker serviks
obat utk kanker serviks
obat untuk kanker serviks
obat tradisional utk kanker serviks
sirsak obat kanker serviks
obat sakit kanker serviks
hello world obat untuk kanker rahim stadium 3
obat herbal kanker rahim stadium 4
obat kanker rahim stadium 1 1
Obat kanker rahim stadium 2
Obat penyakit herpes kelamin pria

# posted by

Unknown : 11:30 AM

تنظيف منازل بالطائف

شركة مكافحة حشرات بالمدينة المنورة
A
شركة تسليك مجارى بالمدينة المنورة

شركة نقل اثاث بالمدينة المنورة

شركة كشف تسربات بالمدينة المنورة

شركة تسليك مجارى بجدة

شركة مكافحة حشرات بجدة

شركة نظافة عامة بجدة

شركة نقل اثاث بجدة

شركة كشف تسربات بجدة

شركة تسليك مجارى بالدمام

شركة تنظيف مسابح بالدمام

شركة تنظيف موكيت بالدمام

شركة مكافحة حشرات بالدمام

شركة كشف تسربات بالدمام

شركة نظافة عامة بالدمام

شركة نقل اثاث بالدمام

شركة تسليك مجارى بالرياض

تخزين اثاث بالرياض

كشف تسربات بالرياض

مكافحة حشرات بالرياض

نقل اثاث بالرياض

تنظيف بخميس مشيط

تنظيف بالطائف

رش مبيدات بجازان

تسليك مجارى بجازان

نظافة بالجوف

# posted by

شركة خدمات منزلية : 5:49 AM

# posted by

Unknown : 1:30 PM

`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`

# posted by

Unknown : 6:36 PM

شركة الروناء
شركة تسليك مجارى بابها
شركة تنظيف بابها
شركة تنظيف منازل بابها شركة رش مبيدات بابها
شركة مكافحة حشرات بابها
شركة نقل اثاث بابها
شركة تنظيف شقق بابها
شركة تنظيف خزانات بابها
شركة نظافة عامة بابها

شركة تسليك مجارى بخميس مشيط
شركة تنظيف خزانات بخميس مشيط
شركة تنظيف بخميس مشيط
شركة رش مبيدات بخميس مشيط
شركة كشف تسريبات بخميس مشيط

# posted by

hosam gamal : 2:42 PM

Best Assignment Helper |
Buy Assignment help online
I am very happy to read this. This is the kind of manual that needs to be given and not the random misinformation that’s at the other blogs. Appreciate your sharing this best posting.

# posted by

Unknown : 7:04 AM

This content is written very well. Your use of formatting when making your points makes your observations very clear and easy to understand. Thank you This content is written very well. Your use of formatting when making your points makes your observations very clear and easy to understand. Thank you..

Need Homework Help | My Homework Help

# posted by

Unknown : 7:05 AM

Do I not destroy my enemies when I make them my friends?
Agen Judi Online Terpercaya

# posted by

Unknown : 12:57 PM

I often follow blogs on a similar topic, and like Singapore resume writing service, but I have never visited your blog before. I added it to favorites and i’ll be your constant reader.

# posted by

AnBlanch : 6:44 PM

such an amazing article.your writing skill very nice.keep sharing this kind of post.
http://awriter.org/rushessaycom/

# posted by

Anonymous : 2:58 PM

لا داعى للقلق وانت تتعامل مع شركة اركان المملكه للتنظيف والمكافحه والتسليك
وغير ذالك من كافه انواع التنظيف فى المملكه السعوديه باكملها اذا
كل ما عليكم هو زياره صفحتنا للتطلع على اقل الاسعار المتاحه
والتى تفى احتياجاتكم الخاصه
0544369605

شركة كشف تسربات المياه بابها

شركة تسليك مجارى بابها

شركة مكافحة حشرات بابها

شركة تنظيف بابها

شركة تنظيف فلل بابها

شركة تنظيف منازل بابها

اتصلوا بنا دائما تجدونا فى كل وقت وكل مكان
لاننا نتعامل بمنتهى الدقه والفعاله والاهميه الكبيره مع شركة
اركان المملكه لاداعى للقلق نحن معك دائمامع شركة اركان المملكه انت فى ايدى امينه لاننا بكل امان وحرفيه فى كافه المجالات الحديثه والعصريه
شركة كشف تسربات المياه بجازان
لدينا الخبره الكبيره فى مجال كشف التسربات اليوميه والتى من الافضل الاهتمام الكامل والشامل بها
شركة نقل اثاث بجازان
هكذا نحن معك دائما فى مجال التسليك والمكافحه فى كل وقت وكل مكان ندعمك بكل جهد
شركة تسليك مجارى بجازان
وايضا فى مدينه نجران لسنا الوحيدون ولكننا متميزون عن غيرنا فى كافه المجالات
شركة تسليك مجارى بنجران
ولدينا الخبره الطويله فى رش المبيدات والمكافحه بكل وقت وكل مكان
شركة رش مبيدات بجازان
ولدينا ايضا باع طويل فى المقاولات لاننا شركة متماسكه ولها الافضليه الكبيره فى هذا المجال
شركة مقاولات بجازان
نتعامل باقل الاسعار الممكنه والمتاحه لدى العميل والوصول الى الدقه الكامله

# posted by

Unknown : 1:58 PM

مع شركة اركان المملكه للتنظيف,ومكافحه الحشرات,وكشف التسربات,وتسليك المجارى,ونقل العفش,وتنظيف البيوت انت
شركة تنظيف منازل بخميس مشيط
تتعامل مع افضل شركة بالمملكه ككل لانها تتعامل باقل الاسعار المتاحه فى مجال العمل
شركة كشف تسربات المياه بخميس مشيط
ونحن نوفر لك كل ما هو جديد وبخصم 30%فى مجال الحساب اذا معنا انت فى كل امان ممكن
اتصل بشركة اركان المملكه لانها الافضل دائما فى كل المجالات
شركة تسليك مجارى بخميس مشيط
هكذا شركة اركان المملكه تقدم الخدمه الممتازه التى بدونها لا تستطيعوا العمل الجاد
اننا نتعامل بالافضليه الكامله لاننا نتعامل بكل الاسعار البسيطه والممكنه
شركة مكافحه حشرات بخميس مشيط
نتعامل باقل الاسعار الممكنه والممتاحه فى هذا المجال وخاصه مدينه خميس مشيط
شركة نقل عفش بخميس مشيط
تحت شعار الراحه الكامله والاداء المتميز والخدمه طول اليوم هكذا الافضليه الكامله لشركه اركان المملكه اذا معنا انت الافضل نقدم لك كافه التسهيلات الممكنه فى هذا المجال
شركة كشف تسربات المياه بالرياض
معنا انت تتعامل بمجال تنظيف المنازل والفلل والقصور وغيرها اذا معنا انت الافضل
شركة نقل عفش بالرياض
اتصلوا نصلكم اينما كنتم بالمملكه فى كافه المجالات ومجال العفش الدائم والفعال هنا وهناك وبكافه اركان المملكه
شركة رش مبيدات بالرياض
مع شركه اركان المملكه الشركه الام التى لها تاريخ وباع كبير وفعال فى هذا المجال وغيره من المجالات المتنوعه والمتوفره فى هذا السياق
شركة اركان المملكه
اذا نحن معك دائما نقدم لك كافه العماله بكل اتقان وامانه وبكافه التسهيلات الممكنه
شركة تنظيف منازل بالرياض
معنا انت تتعامل باقل الاسعار اتصل نصلك اينما كنت وفى كل وقت وكل مان بالمملكه السعوديه
معنا انت فى كل امان اتصل نصلك اينما كنت

# posted by

Unknown : 1:59 PM