Balkinization  

Thursday, September 28, 2006

The Senate Vote

Marty Lederman

65-34 (Snowe not voting). All Republicans but one (Chafee) voted in favor. Democrats voting in favor included Carper, Johnson, Landrieu, Lautenberg, Lieberman, Menendez, Nelson (Fla.), Nelson (Neb.), Pryor, Rockefeller, Salazar and Stabenow.

Comments:

It's good to know there's a few sensable Dems out there.


In any event, I repeat my unanswered question:

What interrogation procedures are ok with you? All we see is you criticizingthe administration but you never offer an alternative set of tactics. Lets assume that KSM was captured or lets say the US captures Zawahiri or some other AQ big shot.

How would YOU interrogate him? What tactics would be acceptable to you? Lay out how it would go.

Let's say he says, "I'm not telling you anything and I'm waiting for my lawyer". Is that the end of it? Should we just say ok?

I have yet to see one liberal explain how terrorists should be interrogated and how we should get information from them. How would you do it? What's acceptable to you? And if he says "I'm not telling you anything" after you've played by CA3 rules and Geneva rules, then what?

Please, enough criticizing Bush. How would you go about it?

I eagerly await your answer
 

Snowe apparently had a death in the family, as hasn't voted in the last two days. Maybe you were mistaken that you saw her?
 

Here is how you interrogate without needing this bill. Google also Koubi and Scharff, star interrogators for Israel and the Luftwaffe, respectively. Both are famed for their skills, yet neither for his violations of Geneva 3.

Odd, that.
 

It's about payback, not interrogation.


I suppose one could actually think that it's wrong to torture American soldiers (or perhaps uniformed soldiers, or however you want to slice it), but okay to torture evil terrorists.
 

In all seriousness, I don't see how different treatment for terror suspects than for "regular" criminals can be justified. No, really.

As I understand it, wanting to subject terror suspects to "enhanced" techniques turns on 1) the desirability of the knowledge they (are assumed to) have, and 2) our willingness to treat terrorists more harshly than "regular" criminals, because we judge them to be more contemptible and less deserving of protections. The first justification is pragmatic, and the second, pseudo-moral. Neither seems workable to me. Rebuttals:

1) It seems to me that "regular" criminals will also sometimes have highly desirable information. Suppose a wacko kidnaps half a dozen young children and locks them up somewhere. They are at risk of starvation or suffocation. And yet the police are forbidden from using "enhanced" techniques. Why? It is extremely important here to extract the whereabouts of the children from the prisoner.

2) Allowing different treatment of a prisoner based on the crime they are suspected of having committed skips a basic protection of a civilized society: it bases decisions on the nature of the suspected crime without having firmly established that the prisoner is, in fact, guilty. To put this another way, even if you think that all terrorists should be tortured, you presumably think it's a great travesty to torture a non-terrorist. But giving yourself license to torture people that are merely suspected of terrorism is a terrific way to ensure you will end up torturing non-terrorists, sooner or later.

Bonus rebuttal to 2): it's not clear to me that terrorist acts are always morally worse than non-terrorist acts, unless we're going to start calling all kinds of criminals "terrorists". Serial rapists, sadistic killers, pedophiles, etc, all seem worthy of the same moral condemnation we reserve for terrorists.

So my first answer would be, whatever measures are permissible for “regular” criminals.

If you want a more aggressive suggestion, here's one that I don't actually support, but that seems at least defensible: torture warrants. If we're going to seriously advance a pragmatic justification for torture, that is, that the information we can reasonably hope to obtain justifies the repugnant act of torture, let's put safeguards in place. If the executive can demonstrate to the judiciary that it has reasonable grounds to believe that a prisoner is withholding critical information that could be extracted with torture, let the judiciary weigh the prisoner's rights against the value of the information, and issue a warrant for the harsh treatment when it is justified. But, I would still see no reason to distinguish between terror suspects and regular criminals.
 

I know SW (ironic name) is a troll, but "liberal" I assume is in the classic sense, such as this being a "liberal democracy" and so forth, right? The conservatives etc. against this thing underline we aren't just talking about the Kennedys of the world.

The Dems voting "aye" have an electoral taint to them. Several are running in November. The rather liberal L. (NJ) is surprising, but maybe he's doing it out of loyalty to M. who is running neck to neck vs. Kean.

Rockefeller's vote underlines the gutless wonder nature of his role on the intel committee, an important one in this area. The fact Sen. Roberts went too far for even him underlines the depths.

Snowe also is running.
 

Well, maiken, you are forthright, and wcw, though less forthrights, is fundamentally in accord, in agreeing with sarahweddington's hypothetical version of the absurd liberal answer: if Khalid Shaikh Mohammed asks for a lawyer, all interrogation must cease. Unfortunately, the American people don't agree with you, but maybe you can convince them at some future date.

Most of the comments here make little sense to me. wcw, why do you we assume that terrrorists are the kind of loser low-lifes who succumb to standard police interrogation techniques? pseudonymous in nc, consider this: if you were (wrongly but reasonably) believed by an American soldier to be an enemy combatant on the battlefield, would you be willing to be killed? I doubt it. Does that mean that American soldiers are not allowed to kill those they believe to be enemy combatants on the battlefield? Your argument proves too much.
 

btw maiken has a very good point.

As to warrants, that would "ruin it" by openly torturing. We don't do that, remember?
 

It's good to know there's a few sensable Dems out there.

That's big of you, so I'll respond in kind with a tip to help you get taken more seriously next time: the word is sensible, not sensable.

But to give my answer your question: interrogation procedures that aren't cruel and that don't torture are OK with me.

And to answer your underlying question: there are numerous examples of how reasonable, patient questioning of even "hardened" suspects can lead to real results. Here are two accounts:
1) "What would Allah do?"
2) "Pray and tell"

...summarized by me here, if you prefer. I invite your focused, finite, and civil discussion there.
 

Thanks for sharing this information. I really like your way of expressing the opinions and sharing the information. It is good to move as chance bring new things in life, paves the way for advancement. I have read a lot of article of this web site by which many of them were being very interesting and uplifting. This information has excellent subject along with excellent description.

click here
click here
click here
click here
click here
click here
 

Harga Blackberry terbaru
Pengecoran Aluminium
Thanks for the tips, maybe I can use this svelte my noesis marketing and Ive been use whatsoever ethnical media in try a interaction and they eff handiwork a big friendliness on me.
 

gPlease chack this articels. The most beautiful home design of Indonesia

desain rumah sederhana

desain rumah

desain rumah murah
 

Please chack this articels. The most beautiful home design of Indonesia

desain rumah sederhana

desain rumah

Desain rumah minimalis

desain rumah murah
 

It's good to know there's a few sensable Dems out there.


In any event, I repeat my unanswered question:

What interrogation procedures are ok with you? All we see is you criticizingthe administration but you never offer an alternative set of tactics. Lets assume that KSM was captured or lets say the US captures Zawahiri or some other AQ big shot.

How would YOU interrogate him? What tactics would be acceptable to you? Lay out how it would go.

Let's say he says, "I'm not telling you anything and I'm waiting for my lawyer". Is that the end of it? Should we just say ok?

I have yet to see one liberal explain how terrorists should be interrogated and how we should get information from them. How would you do it? What's acceptable to you? And if he says "I'm not telling you anything" after you've played by CA3 rules and Geneva rules, then what?

Please, enough criticizing Bush. How would you go about it?

I eagerly await your answer

Desain rumah minimalis

Desain rumah sederhana minimalis

Desain rumah minimalis modern

Desain rumah
 

Snowe apparently had a death in the family, as hasn't voted in the last two days. Maybe you were mistaken that you saw her?


Desain rumah minimalis modrn 2 lantai

Desain rumah minimalis

Desain rumah sederhana minimalis

Desain rumah minimalis modern
 

Sometimes I wonder if the Bush Admin thought up all this convoluted mess just so they could sound insane and piss off the Dems.

At the end of the debate, McCaine said that all US Officials must comply with Common Article III, even if they can't be punished for less than Grave Breaches. If this is true, wouldn't it allow field agents to legally disobey an order by refusing to employ certain procedures?

But anyway, the combination of harsh techniques and the loss of habeas corpus is the worst possible situation, not on constitutional or moral grounds, but simply on long term progress against terrorism.

If these men were true POWs, then harsh treatment wouldn't matter as much: when POWs return to their homeland after the battle is over, they are under the control of their government. In addition, it is obvious that POWs don't need habeas corpus to eventually get a hearing, and maybe released regardless of individual actions.

But terrorists, or those thought to be terrorists are a special case. They represent a Nation of One. Mistreatment during detention of could easily create a threat where one didn't exist. Detainees become dangerous due to the actions of our government. We can't simply set them loose since there is no government to take them.

So it is important to have either effective habeas rights, or strict policies for detainee treatment. Maybe the CIA will consider this and go easy on their captives until habeas has been tested in the Courts.

Btw, how long before the habeas stripping is challenged? Won't it start right away?

pengertian PCI
 

I have a question for you. What would you say (let's suppose that you were one of the senators who just voted for the bill) to an innocent man, such as the Canadian whom Bush sent to Syria to be tortured, and who had spent ten months in a cell being tortured, if you had to meet him face to face? Let's assume, however, that the meeting was in a prison, because, unlike the Canadian, my hypothetical innocent man was not being charged but was being held and tortured indefinitely. Bahasa Inggris
 

Well, maiken, you are forthright, and wcw, though less forthrights, is fundamentally in accord, in agreeing with sarahweddington's hypothetical version of the absurd liberal answer: if Khalid Shaikh Mohammed asks for a lawyer, all interrogation must cease. Unfortunately, the American people don't agree with you, but maybe you can convince them at some future date.

Most of the comments here make little sense to me. wcw, why do you we assume that terrrorists are the kind of loser low-lifes who succumb to standard police interrogation techniques? pseudonymous in nc, consider this: if you were (wrongly but reasonably) believed by an American soldier to be an enemy combatant on the battlefield, would you be willing to be killed? I doubt it. Does that mean that American soldiers are not allowed to kill those they believe to be enemy combatants on the battlefield? Your argument proves too much.

Visit My Blog ::

Arti Komputer
Pengertian Komputer
Apa itu komputer
pengertian komputer menurut para ahli
apa yang di maksud komputer
 

This comment has been removed by the author.
 

It's good to know there's a few sensable Dems out there.


In any event, I repeat my unanswered question:

What interrogation procedures are ok with you? All we see is you criticizingthe administration but you never offer an alternative set of tactics. Lets assume that KSM was captured or lets say the US captures Zawahiri or some other AQ big shot.

How would YOU interrogate him? What tactics would be acceptable to you? Lay out how it would go.

Let's say he says, "I'm not telling you anything and I'm waiting for my lawyer". Is that the end of it? Should we just say ok?

I have yet to see one liberal explain how terrorists should be interrogated and how we should get information from them. How would you do it? What's acceptable to you? And if he says "I'm not telling you anything" after you've played by CA3 rules and Geneva rules, then what?

Please, enough criticizing Bush. How would you go about it?

I eagerly await your answer

mempercepat kinerja komputer
 

This afternoon I've read in your place, and quite interesting information submitted. If we are diligent reading will certainly add to the knowledge and insight. Thank you, continue to work.

Contoh simple present tense
 

http://liburanonline.com/readblog.php?id=16 tour singapore , singapore murah wisata singapore , paket liburan singapore
http://juragandropship.com jual gildan murah , jual gildan , paket gildan
http://sablon-kaos.co.id sablon kaos murah , sablon kaos , sablon kaos murah
http://jamtangancasio.co.id jam tangan casio, pusat jam tangan casio, jam tangan casio murah
http://indoneka.com/aksesoris_mobil aksesoris mobil
http://hargaterupdate.com harga terupdate handphone
http://valqis.com
http://senyumbayi.com
http://db-korea.blogspot.com
http://db-travel.blogspot.com
http://astonmartinvanquishnew.blogspot.com
http://2015tophairstyles.blogspot.com
http://contohdesainrumahminimalis.com
http://wallpapersizehd.com wallpapers HD
http://vierzha.com

 

http://www.contohdesainrumahminimalis.com/2014/10/pintu-rumah-minimalis-modern.html

 

what a beautiful article, i love this website, give readers a usefull informations, keep writing bro.. look back on my website bedroom design ideas
 

http://terakurat.com/tangga-lagu-indonesia-terbaru/
 

http://www.terakurat.com/cara-membuat-twitter/
 

kami akan memberikan anda bagaimana tips cara membuat twitter agar supaya dan jika dapur rumah minimalis jelek anda bisa memakai tempat service ac mobil dari kami untuk membersihkannya
 

http://pliggpoker.pun.bz/belajar-main-poker-di-asiapoker77.xhtml
http://belajarcopi.mwb-id.com/belajar-maen-judi-sbobet-338a.xhtml
http://tukangcopi.mwb.im/link-game-sbobet-338a.xhtml
http://prisaseo.bravesites.com/entries/general/link-asiapoker77-dengan-promo-awal-bulan
http://radit.bravesites.com/entries/general/promo-games-casino-sbobet-338a-bonus-5-
http://darmajaya.over-blog.com/2015/02/tangkasnet-memberikan-promo-bonus-menarik-by-agent855bet.html
http://situscmd368.over-blog.com/2015/02/strategi-khusus-dalam-bermain-poker-online.html
http://situs368bet.over-blog.com/2015/02/cara-membaca-poker-sifat-lawan-anda.html
http://situscbo855.over-blog.com/2015/02/keuntungan-dan-kerugian-bermain-poker-online.html
http://bukuagen.over-blog.com/2015/02/poker-online-menceritakan-seni-mengamati-lawan-yang-tak-terlihat.html
 

http://www.zetapedia.com/2015/01/surat-dinas-terbaru-2015.html
http://www.zetapedia.com/2015/01/contoh-surat-resmi-surat-niaga-surat.html
http://www.zetapedia.com/2014/11/contoh-surat-pemberitahuan.html
http://www.zetapedia.com/2015/02/contoh-surat-dinas-surat-resmi-surat.html
http://www.zetapedia.com/2014/11/contoh-daftar-riwayat-hidup-terbaru.html
http://www.zetapedia.com/2014/12/10-contoh-surat-dinas-resmi-dan-tidak.html
 

It's good to know there's a few sensable Dems out there. modern living room
 

Living Room Ideas Sarah Weddington: I have a question for you. What would you say (let's suppose that you were one of the senators who just voted for the bill) to an innocent man, such as the Canadian whom Bush sent to Syria to be tortured, and who had spent ten months in a cell being tortured, if you had to meet him face to face? Let's assume, however, that the meeting was in a prison, because, unlike the Canadian, my hypothetical innocent man was not being charged but was being held and tortured indefinitely.
 


شركة الفؤاد للخدمات بالرياض
شركة الفؤاد للخدمات بالرياض
شركة الفؤاد للخدمات بالرياض
شركة الفؤاد للخدمات بالرياض
شركة الفؤاد للخدمات بالرياض
شركة الفؤاد للخدمات بالرياض

شركة الفؤاد للخدمات بالرياض
اعمال الصيانة بالرياض
شركة رش مبيد ومكافحة حشرات بالرياض
شركة تسليك مجارى بالرياض
شركة دهانات بالرياض
شركة عزل خزانات واسطح بالرياض
شركة نقل عفش بالرياض
شركة تنظيف فلل وقصور بالرياض
شركة تنظيف شقق بالرياض
شركة تنظيف واجهات بالرياض
شركة تنظيف مسابح بالرياض

...........................................................................................................

0566143611 - 0566822461 شركة خبراء المملكة لخدمات التنظيف
شركة مكافحة حشرات بالرياض 0566143611 - 0566822461
0566143611 - 0566822461 شركة تنظيف فلل وشقق بالرياض
0566143611 - 0566822461 شركة عزل و تنظيف الخزانات
0566143611 - 0566822461 شركة نقل وتخزين أثاث بالرياض
0566143611 - 0566822461 شركة تنظيف قصور بالرياض
0566143611 - 0566822461 شركة تخزين أثاث بالرياض
0566143611 - 0566822461 شركة تنظيف خزانات بالرياض
 


شركة الفؤاد للخدمات بالرياض
شركة الفؤاد للخدمات بالرياض
شركة الفؤاد للخدمات بالرياض
شركة الفؤاد للخدمات بالرياض
شركة الفؤاد للخدمات بالرياض
شركة الفؤاد للخدمات بالرياض

شركة الفؤاد للخدمات بالرياض
اعمال الصيانة بالرياض
شركة رش مبيد ومكافحة حشرات بالرياض
شركة تسليك مجارى بالرياض
شركة دهانات بالرياض
شركة عزل خزانات واسطح بالرياض
شركة نقل عفش بالرياض
شركة تنظيف فلل وقصور بالرياض
شركة تنظيف شقق بالرياض
شركة تنظيف واجهات بالرياض
شركة تنظيف مسابح بالرياض

...........................................................................................................

0566143611 - 0566822461 شركة خبراء المملكة لخدمات التنظيف
شركة مكافحة حشرات بالرياض 0566143611 - 0566822461
0566143611 - 0566822461 شركة تنظيف فلل وشقق بالرياض
0566143611 - 0566822461 شركة عزل و تنظيف الخزانات
0566143611 - 0566822461 شركة نقل وتخزين أثاث بالرياض
0566143611 - 0566822461 شركة تنظيف قصور بالرياض
0566143611 - 0566822461 شركة تخزين أثاث بالرياض
0566143611 - 0566822461 شركة تنظيف خزانات بالرياض
 

http://www.goldst2r.com/%D8%B1%D8%B4-%D9%85%D8%A8%D9%8A%D8%AF%D8%A7%D8%AA-%D8%A8%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%B1%D9%8A%D8%A7%D8%B6/%D8%B4%D8%B1%D9%83%D8%A9-%D9%85%D9%83%D8%A7%D9%81%D8%AD%D8%A9-%D8%A7%D9%84%D9%86%D9%85%D9%84-%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%A3%D8%A8%D9%8A%D8%B6-%D8%A8%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%B1%D9%8A%D8%A7%D8%B6/#https://www.facebook.com/pages/-----0566397006/1584962385108689?__mref=message_bubble
 

helo admin blog, i am very happy ro post here , nice blog anda those articles, i;ll be back soon, feeding frenzy
 

coming to this comment field is most grateful to put some words, thanks for this information and hope be solved soon for the problems.
good evening from me ^_^
beauty face
 

you should find a best and known lawyer near you and make a deal to win.
hope solved soon, i am sorry for my fault
feeding fish in the sea
 

Stromanbieter
 

kembali lagi ke blog untuk dapat mencari informasi terbaru kali ini
 

You made such an interesting piece to read, giving every subject enlightenment for us to gain knowledge. Thanks for sharing the such information with us to read this Tips seputar dunia properti
 

coming to this comment field is most grateful to put some words, thanks for this information and hope be solved soon for the problems.
good evening from me ^_^ http://www.desainrumahmini.com

http://info-smartphone-android.blogspot.com
 

Your web site provided us with valuable information to work on. You've done an impressive task and our whole neighborhood can be thankful to you. Also visit my web site :

Modern Living Room

 

best offers for indiatoday


 

best offers for indiatimes


 

best offers for freecharge


 

Java Training institutue in US

 

best offers for foodpanda


 

best offers for floweraura


 

Thanks for the nice blog. It was very useful for me. I'm happy I found this blog. Thank you for sharing with us,I too always learn something new from your post.
info loker, loker terbaru, lowongan kerja terbaru, lowongan kerja bulan ini | www.lokerpantura.com | Cara Diet Sehat
 

best deals for printvenue


 

very nice article.thanks for sharing the post..!
Application Packaging Training institutue in US


 

very nice article.thanks for sharing the post..!
Android Training institutue in US


 

very nice article.thanks for sharing the post..!
Abinitio Training institutue in US


 

very nice article.Thanks for sharing the post..!
Training institutue in US


 

very nice article.Thanks for sharing the post..!
OBIEE Real Time Support


 

very nice article.Thanks for sharing the post..!
Ruby Real Time Support

SAP XI Real Time Support


 

very nice article.Thanks for sharing the post..!
Tibco Real Time Support

Amazon Web Server Real Time Support


 

very nice article
Tableau Real Time Support

Teradata Real Time Support


 

very nice article.Thanks for sharing the post...!
SQL Server 2012 DBA Real Time Support

SQL Server 2012 Real Time Support


 

very nice.it will be very useful to all of them.Thanks for sharing The post.
Solaris Real Time Support

SQL and Plsql Real Time Support


 

very nice article.Thanks for sharing the post...!
SCCM 2012 Real Time Support

Selenium Real Time Support


 

very nice article.Thanks for sharing the post...!
SAP Success Factors Real Time Support

SAP WebDynpro Real Time Support


 

very nice article.Thanks for sharing the post...!
SAP MM Real Time Support

SAP SD Real Time Support


 

very nice article.Thanks for sharing the post...!SAP Hana Real Time Support

SAP HR Abap Real Time Support


 

very nice article.thanks for sharing the post...!
SAP Bw Hana Real Time Support

SAP Fico Real Time Support


 

very nice article.Thanks for sharing the post..!
SAP ABAP Real Time Support

SAP Basis Real Time Support


 

very nice article
Oracle SOA Real Time Support

SalesForce Real Time Support


 

very nice article.thanks for the information ...!
Oracle 11g RAC Real Time Support

Oracle DBA Real Time Support


 

very nice article.thanks for sharing the post!
Microstrategy Real Time Support

MSBI Real Time Support


 

very nice article.thanks for sharing the post...!
Java Real Time Support

QTP &QC Real Time Support


 

very nice article.thanks for sharing the post...!
Hyperion Real Time Support

Informatica Real Time Support


 

very nice article.thanks for sharing the post...!
ETL Testing Real Time Support

Hadoop Real Time Support


 

very nice article
Cognos Real Time Support

DataStage Real Time Support


 

very nice article.Thanks for sharing the post...!
Please visit my site on Birthday Invitations Templates
 

Your web site provided us with valuable information to work on. You've done an impressive task and our whole neighborhood can be thankful to you. Also visit my web site :

Living Room Design

Living Room Remodel

Modern Living Room

Living Room Realty
 

Tibco Training


 

http://www.gotrainings.com/etl-testing-online-training/
http://www.gotrainings.com/hadoop-online-training/
http://www.gotrainings.com/hyperion-online-training/
http://www.gotrainings.com/informatica-online-training/

 

http://www.gotrainings.com/
http://www.gotrainings.com/ab-initio-online-training/
http://www.gotrainings.com/amazon-web-server-online-training/
http://www.gotrainings.com/application-packaging-online-training/

 

bengkel AC Mobil berganrais
Hajar Jahanam Jakarta murah
Obat EJakulasi Dini terbaik
 

very nice article.Thanks for sharing the post...
Informatica Training institutue in US


 

very nice article.
Informatica Corporate Training


 

very nice article.Thanks for sharing the information.
Best Informatica Online Training institute From India|UK|US|Canada|Australia


 

very nice article.Thanks for sharing the post...!
Informatica Online Training


 

very nice article.Thanks for sharing the post...!
Informatica


 

very nice article.Thanks for sharing the post...!
Informatica Training


 

very nice article.Thanks for sharing the information.
Informatica Online Training institute


 

very nice article.Thanks for sharing the post...!
Best Informatica Online Training institute From India|UK|US|Canada|Australia


 

very nice article.Thanks for sharing the post..!
Informatica Online Training By Real Time Faculties


 

very nice article.Thanks for sharing the post...!
Informatica Corporate Training


 

Post a Comment

Older Posts
Newer Posts
Home