Balkinization  

Monday, May 01, 2006

West Wing and the Constitution (II)

Sandy Levinson

Tonight's West Wing lesson in constitutional structure involved choosing a new vice president following the unanticipated death of Leo McGarity. The upstanding president elect refuses simply to "order" the 272 Democratic electors to vote for his choice, the Democratic governor of Pennsylvania, because this would in fact be undemocratic. He will, therefore, apparently wait until after his inauguration to formally nominate him and, therefore, subject him to confirmation by the House and the Senate, as was the case with Gerald Ford and then Nelson Rockefeller. On the other hand, he fears that Republican senators, who hold a majority, will refuse to confirm Baker, not least because he is already the front runner for 2012. So it appears that Santos will not only be inaugurated without there being a vice president, but also that the office might be vacant for at least sesveral weeks, assuming that the Republicans eventually submit to public pressure. Since the House is now Democratic, the person next in line is the Speaker, but an earlier program gave no reason to believe that the new Speaker is remotely fit to be president.

So is this just another stupidity of the Constitution? And, if so, what precisely is the stupidity? Is it having a vice president at all? David Currie, among others, believes that the basic mistake in 1803 (when the 12th Amendment was added to the Constitution to prevent another fiasco like 1800) was retaining the vice presidency at all. Most countries, even with presidential systems, seem able to do without one. (There's a marvelous interview with Carlos Fuentes in today's Times Magazine explaining why Mexico has no vice president.) Or is it that a partisan House or Senate would indeed try to deprive the President of his/her choice? But why SHOULD a president simply be able to pick by fiat his/her successor, unless we do indeed treat the president as a quasi-monarch? Imagine that Dick Chency indeed leaves office, and that Bush decides that the best replacement is Donald Rumsfeld. (Even I can't imagine that he would be so incredibly stupid, but it's my hypothetical.) Surely the Democrats would be under no duty to say "well, it's his choice." We would surely expect them to filibuster on the altogether correct grounds that he is unfit to be President (unlike, say, John McCain).

There would be no need for this discussion were it not for the sad and untimely death of John Spencer, a fine actor who is much missed. And I fear that the replacement for West Wing will not be the only program on TV that has actually integrated into its story line a number of obscure, but highly important, issues of constitutional structure.

Comments:

Assuming that Santos runs for re-election, Baker can't run until 2016. That is, something happened to the years of Presidential elections in the West Wing world.
 

Allowing the elected President to chose who replaces him in the event he's incapacitated, is a sort of proxy for democracy, assuming the President would pick somebody like himself.

To the extent VPs are chosen to "ballance the ticket", instead, of course, it's an awfully BAD proxy...
 

Commander-in-Chief with Geena Davis, if it survives, might raise issues like this to some extent. Anyway, w/o WW, there will likely be a few shots at replacing it with a program in that ilk.

Anyway, Santos has the right sentiment, but the EC is what we have now. The EC picks the VP. Election Day is about appointing electors. The EC will pick Baker (his choice) and that will be that. I guess Baker could resign ...

Another possibility is that a few dissident electors do not pick Baker. If there is no majority, the Senate (Republican) chooses the VP among the top two candidates.

The 20A deals with a situation when there is a death and the choice goes to the Senate. I guess it should have also dealt with a death between Election Day and Electoral College Day.
 

Is it actually possible for Santos to order his electors to vote for his choice? I believe that several states require electors by law to vote for the person whose name appears on the ballot.

Meanwhile, Commander in Chief is setting up another crisis. The Vice President, whose TV name I forget but he's based on Wes Clark, has resigned. The President is about to get ill, which Speaker Templeton seems to be planning to use as an excuse to invoke the 25th amendment and take over.
 

Er, 2014. West Wing is off by two years: Bartlett took office in January of 98, so that the show, starting the subsequent fall, shows them nine months into office. The most recent primaries, of course, started a year early; presumably, the parties and the states made some deal. And with the conventions in May? And a year-long campaign leading up to generals in May? In fact, I think that that's a trick of the camera. But, yeah, Baker will be running in 2014, probably.
 

bingo
bingo online
online bingo
bingo casino
play bingo
internet bingo
play bingo online
play online bingo
bingo casinos
bingo sites
bingo web sites
bingo websites
top bingo casinos
best bingo casinos
online bingo casinos
bingo casinos online
internet bingo casinos
bingo
bingo online
online bingo
bingo casino
play bingo
internet bingo
play bingo online
play online bingo
bingo casinos
bingo sites
bingo web sites
bingo websites
top bingo casinos
best bingo casinos
online bingo casinos
bingo casinos online
internet bingo casinos
hoodia
hoodia diet pills
hoodia gordonii
pure hoodia
hoodia side effects
hoodia patch
hoodia prices
buy hoodia
compare hoodia
best hoodia
hoodia pills
hoodia pill
hoodia diet pill
hoodia diet
hoodia
hoodia diet pills
hoodia gordonii
pure hoodia
hoodia side effects
hoodia patch
hoodia prices
buy hoodia
compare hoodia
best hoodia
hoodia pills
hoodia pill
hoodia diet pill
hoodia diet
Bingo Web Sites
Bingo Web Sites Contact Us 
Bingo Web Sites Sitemap
Bingo Web Sites Articles
Bingo Web Sites Support
Top Bingo Casinos Linkdomain
Bingo Websites
Saints And Sinner Bingo Contact Us
Saints And Sinner Bingo Sitemap
Bingo Articles 1
Online Internet Best Top Bingo Casinos Articles 1
Saints And Sinner Bingo Faq
Saints And Sinner Bingo Support
Bingo Websites Index 1
Bingo Web Sites Index 1
Casino Games Info
Baccarat
Backgammon
Blackjack
Craps
Keno
Poker
Roulette
Slots
Sportsbook
Video Poker
Best Bingo Casinos Linkdomain
Hoodia Prices
Contact
Site Map
Articles
Support
Hoodia Prices Index 1
Hoodia Side Effects Index 1
Hoodia Patch Index 1
Compare Hoodia Linkdomain
Hoodia Prices
Articles
Contact
Sitemap
Support
Hoodia Prices Index 1
Hoodia Side Effects Index 1
Hoodia Patch Index 1
Best Hoodia Linkdomain
Bingo Articles
Hoodia Side Effects 452 Hoodia Side Effects 453 Hoodia Side Effects 454 Hoodia Side Effects 455 Hoodia Side Effects 456 Hoodia Side Effects 457 Hoodia Side Effects 458 Hoodia Side Effects 459 Hoodia Side Effects 460 Hoodia Side Effects 461 Hoodia Side Effects 462 Hoodia Side Effects 463 Hoodia Side Effects 464 Hoodia Side Effects 465 Hoodia Side Effects 466 Hoodia Side Effects 467 Hoodia Side Effects 468 Hoodia Side Effects 469 Hoodia Side Effects 470 Hoodia Side Effects 471 Hoodia Side Effects 472 Hoodia Side Effects 473 Hoodia Side Effects 474 Hoodia Side Effects 475 Hoodia Side Effects 476 Hoodia Side Effects 477 Hoodia Side Effects 478 Hoodia Side Effects 479 Hoodia Side Effects 480 Hoodia Side Effects 481 Hoodia Side Effects 482 Hoodia Side Effects 483 Hoodia Side Effects 484 Hoodia Side Effects 485 Hoodia Side Effects 486 Hoodia Side Effects 487 Hoodia Side Effects 488 Hoodia Side Effects 489 Hoodia Side Effects 490 Hoodia Side Effects 491 Hoodia Side Effects 492 Hoodia Side Effects 493 Hoodia Side Effects 494 Hoodia Side Effects 495 Hoodia Side Effects 496 Hoodia Side Effects 497 Hoodia Side Effects 498 Hoodia Side Effects 499 Hoodia Side Effects 500 Hoodia Side Effects 501 Hoodia Side Effects 502 Hoodia Side Effects 503 Hoodia Side Effects 504 Hoodia Side Effects 505 Hoodia Side Effects 506 Hoodia Side Effects 507 Hoodia Side Effects 508 Hoodia Side Effects 509 Hoodia Side Effects 510 Hoodia Side Effects 511 Hoodia Side Effects 512 Hoodia Side Effects 513 Hoodia Side Effects 514 Hoodia Side Effects 515 Hoodia Side Effects 516 Hoodia Side Effects 517 Hoodia Side Effects 518 Hoodia Side Effects 519 Hoodia Side Effects 520 Hoodia Side Effects 521 Hoodia Side Effects 522 Hoodia Side Effects 523 Hoodia Side Effects 524 Hoodia Side Effects 525 Hoodia Side Effects 526 Hoodia Side Effects 527 Hoodia Side Effects 528 Hoodia Side Effects 529 Hoodia Side Effects 530 Hoodia Side Effects 531 Hoodia Side Effects 532 Hoodia Side Effects 533 Hoodia Side Effects 534 Hoodia Side Effects 535 Hoodia Side Effects 536 Hoodia Side Effects 537 Hoodia Side Effects 538 Hoodia Side Effects 539 Hoodia Side Effects 540 Hoodia Side Effects 541 Hoodia Side Effects 542 Hoodia Side Effects 543 Hoodia Side Effects 544 Hoodia Side Effects 545 Hoodia Side Effects 546 Hoodia Side Effects 547 Hoodia Side Effects 548 Hoodia Side Effects 549 Hoodia Side Effects 550 Hoodia Side Effects 551 Hoodia Side Effects 552 Hoodia Side Effects 553 Hoodia Side Effects 554 Hoodia Side Effects 555 Hoodia Side Effects 556 Hoodia Side Effects 557 Hoodia Side Effects 558 Hoodia Side Effects 559 Hoodia Side Effects 560 Hoodia Side Effects 561 Hoodia Side Effects 562 Hoodia Side Effects 563 Hoodia Side Effects 564 Hoodia Side Effects 565 Hoodia Side Effects 566 Hoodia Side Effects 567 Hoodia Side Effects 568 Hoodia Side Effects 569 Hoodia Side Effects 570 Hoodia Side Effects 571 Hoodia Side Effects 572 Hoodia Side Effects 573 Hoodia Side Effects 574 Hoodia Side Effects 575 Hoodia Side Effects 576 Hoodia Side Effects 577 Hoodia Side Effects 578 Hoodia Side Effects 579 Hoodia Side Effects 580 Hoodia Side Effects 581 Hoodia Side Effects 582 Hoodia Side Effects 583 Hoodia Side Effects 584 Hoodia Side Effects 585 Hoodia Side Effects 586 Hoodia Side Effects 587 Hoodia Side Effects 588 Hoodia Side Effects 589 Hoodia Side Effects 590 Hoodia Side Effects 591 Hoodia Side Effects 592 Hoodia Side Effects 593 Hoodia Side Effects 594 Hoodia Side Effects 595 Hoodia Side Effects 596 Hoodia Side Effects 597 Hoodia Side Effects 598 Hoodia Side Effects 599 Hoodia Side Effects 600 Hoodia Side Effects 601 Hoodia Side Effects 602 Hoodia Side Effects 603 Hoodia Side Effects 604 Hoodia Side Effects 605 Hoodia Side Effects 606 Hoodia Side Effects 607 Hoodia Side Effects 608 Hoodia Side Effects 609 Hoodia Side Effects 610 Hoodia Side Effects 611 Hoodia Side Effects 612 Hoodia Side Effects 613 Hoodia Side Effects 614 Hoodia Side Effects 615 Hoodia Side Effects 616 Hoodia Side Effects 617 Hoodia Side Effects 618 Hoodia Side Effects 619 Hoodia Side Effects 620 Hoodia Side Effects 621 Hoodia Side Effects 622 Hoodia Side Effects 623 Hoodia Side Effects 624 Hoodia Side Effects 625 Hoodia Side Effects 626 Hoodia Side Effects 627 Hoodia Side Effects 628 Hoodia Side Effects 629 Hoodia Side Effects 630 Hoodia Side Effects 631 Hoodia Side Effects 632 Hoodia Side Effects 633 Hoodia Side Effects 634 Hoodia Side Effects 635 Hoodia Side Effects 636 Hoodia Side Effects 637 Hoodia Side Effects 638 Hoodia Side Effects 639 Hoodia Side Effects 640 Hoodia Side Effects 641 Hoodia Side Effects 642 Hoodia Side Effects 643 Hoodia Side Effects 644 Hoodia Side Effects 645 Hoodia Side Effects 646 Hoodia Side Effects 647 Hoodia Side Effects 648 Hoodia Side Effects 649 Hoodia Side Effects 650 Hoodia Side Effects 651 Hoodia Side Effects 652 Hoodia Side Effects 653 Hoodia Side Effects 654 Hoodia Side Effects 655 Hoodia Side Effects 656 Hoodia Side Effects 657 Hoodia Side Effects 658 Hoodia Side Effects 659 Hoodia Side Effects 660 Hoodia Side Effects 661 Hoodia Side Effects 662 Hoodia Side Effects 663 Hoodia Side Effects 664 Hoodia Side Effects 665 Hoodia Side Effects 666 Hoodia Side Effects 667 Hoodia Side Effects 668 Hoodia Side Effects 669 Hoodia Side Effects 670 Hoodia Side Effects 671 Hoodia Side Effects 672 Hoodia Side Effects 673 Hoodia Side Effects 674 Hoodia Side Effects 675 Hoodia Side Effects 676 Hoodia Side Effects 677 Hoodia Side Effects 678 Hoodia Side Effects 679 Hoodia Side Effects 680 Hoodia Side Effects 681 Hoodia Side Effects 682 Hoodia Side Effects 683 Hoodia Side Effects 684 Hoodia Side Effects 685 Hoodia Side Effects 686 Hoodia Side Effects 687 Hoodia Side Effects 688 Hoodia Side Effects 689 Hoodia Side Effects 690 Hoodia Side Effects 691 Hoodia Side Effects 692 Hoodia Side Effects 693 Hoodia Side Effects 694 Hoodia Side Effects 695 Hoodia Side Effects 696 Hoodia Side Effects 697 Hoodia Side Effects 698 Hoodia Side Effects 699 Hoodia Side Effects 700 Hoodia Side Effects 701 Hoodia Side Effects 702 Hoodia Side Effects 703 Hoodia Side Effects 704 Hoodia Side Effects 705 Hoodia Side Effects 706 Hoodia Side Effects 707 Hoodia Side Effects 708 Hoodia Side Effects 709 Hoodia Side Effects 710 Hoodia Side Effects 711 Hoodia Side Effects 712 Hoodia Side Effects 713 Hoodia Side Effects 714 Hoodia Side Effects 715 Hoodia Side Effects 716 Hoodia Side Effects 717 Hoodia Side Effects 718 Hoodia Side Effects 719 Hoodia Side Effects 720 Hoodia Side Effects 721 Hoodia Side Effects 722 Hoodia Side Effects 723 Hoodia Side Effects 724 Hoodia Side Effects 725 Hoodia Side Effects 726 Hoodia Side Effects 727 Hoodia Side Effects 728 Hoodia Side Effects 729 Hoodia Side Effects 730 Hoodia Side Effects 731 Hoodia Side Effects 732 Hoodia Side Effects 733 Hoodia Side Effects 734 Hoodia Side Effects 735 Hoodia Side Effects 736 Hoodia Side Effects 737 Hoodia Side Effects 738 Hoodia Side Effects 739 Hoodia Side Effects 740 Hoodia Side Effects 741 Hoodia Side Effects 742 Hoodia Side Effects 743 Hoodia Side Effects 744 Hoodia Side Effects 745 Hoodia Side Effects 746 Hoodia Side Effects 747 Hoodia Side Effects 748 Hoodia Side Effects 749 Hoodia Side Effects 750 Hoodia Side Effects 751 Hoodia Side Effects 752 Hoodia Side Effects 753 Hoodia Side Effects 754 Hoodia Side Effects 755 Hoodia Side Effects 756 Hoodia Side Effects 757 Hoodia Side Effects 758 Hoodia Side Effects 759 Hoodia Side Effects 760 Hoodia Side Effects 761 Hoodia Side Effects 762 Hoodia Side Effects 763 Hoodia Side Effects 764 Hoodia Side Effects 765 Hoodia Side Effects 766 Hoodia Side Effects 767 Hoodia Side Effects 768 Hoodia Side Effects 769 Hoodia Side Effects 770 Hoodia Side Effects 771 Hoodia Side Effects 772 Hoodia Side Effects 773 Hoodia Side Effects 774 Hoodia Side Effects 775 Hoodia Side Effects 776 Hoodia Side Effects 777 Hoodia Side Effects 778 Hoodia Side Effects 779 Hoodia Side Effects 780 Hoodia Side Effects 781 Hoodia Side Effects 782 Hoodia Side Effects 783 Hoodia Side Effects 784 Hoodia Side Effects 785 Hoodia Side Effects 786 Hoodia Side Effects 787 Hoodia Side Effects 788 Hoodia Side Effects 789 Hoodia Side Effects 790 Hoodia Side Effects 791 Hoodia Side Effects 792 Hoodia Side Effects 793 Hoodia Side Effects 794 Hoodia Side Effects 795 Hoodia Side Effects 796 Hoodia Side Effects 797 Hoodia Side Effects 798 Hoodia Side Effects 799 Hoodia Side Effects 800 Hoodia Side Effects 801 Hoodia Side Effects 802 Hoodia Side Effects 803 Hoodia Side Effects 804 Hoodia Side Effects 805 Hoodia Side Effects 806 Hoodia Side Effects 807 Hoodia Side Effects 808 Hoodia Side Effects 809 Hoodia Side Effects 810 Hoodia Side Effects 811 Hoodia Side Effects 812 Hoodia Side Effects 813 Hoodia Side Effects 814 Hoodia Side Effects 815 Hoodia Side Effects 816 Hoodia Side Effects 817 Hoodia Side Effects 818 Hoodia Side Effects 819 Hoodia Side Effects 820 Hoodia Side Effects 821 Hoodia Side Effects 822 Hoodia Side Effects 823 Hoodia Side Effects 824 Hoodia Side Effects 825 Hoodia Side Effects 826 Hoodia Side Effects 827 Hoodia Side Effects 828 Hoodia Side Effects 829 Hoodia Side Effects 830 Hoodia Side Effects 831 Hoodia Side Effects 832 Hoodia Side Effects 833 Hoodia Side Effects 834 Hoodia Side Effects 835 Hoodia Side Effects 836 Hoodia Side Effects 837 Hoodia Side Effects 838 Hoodia Side Effects 839 Hoodia Side Effects 840 Hoodia Side Effects 841 Hoodia Side Effects 842 Hoodia Side Effects 843 Hoodia Side Effects 844 Hoodia Side Effects 845 Hoodia Side Effects 846 Hoodia Side Effects 847 Hoodia Side Effects 848 Hoodia Side Effects 849 Hoodia Side Effects 850 Hoodia Side Effects 851 Hoodia Side Effects 852 Hoodia Side Effects 853 Hoodia Side Effects 854 Hoodia Side Effects 855 Hoodia Side Effects 856 Hoodia Side Effects 857 Hoodia Side Effects 858 Hoodia Side Effects 859 Hoodia Side Effects 860 Hoodia Side Effects 861 Hoodia Side Effects 862 Hoodia Side Effects 863 Hoodia Side Effects 864 Hoodia Side Effects 865 Hoodia Side Effects 866 Hoodia Side Effects 867 Hoodia Side Effects 868 Hoodia Side Effects 869 Hoodia Side Effects 870 Hoodia Side Effects 871 Hoodia Side Effects 872 Hoodia Side Effects 873 Hoodia Side Effects 874 Hoodia Side Effects 875 Hoodia Side Effects 876 Hoodia Side Effects 877 Hoodia Side Effects 878 Hoodia Side Effects 879 Hoodia Side Effects 880 Hoodia Side Effects 881 Hoodia Side Effects 882 Hoodia Side Effects 883 Hoodia Side Effects 884 Hoodia Side Effects 885 Hoodia Side Effects 886 Hoodia Side Effects 887 Hoodia Side Effects 888 Hoodia Side Effects 889 Hoodia Side Effects 890 Hoodia Side Effects 891 Hoodia Side Effects 892 Hoodia Side Effects 893 Hoodia Side Effects 894 Hoodia Side Effects 895 Hoodia Side Effects 896 Hoodia Side Effects 897 Hoodia Side Effects 898 Hoodia Side Effects 899 Hoodia Side Effects 900 Hoodia Side Effects 901 Hoodia Side Effects 902 Hoodia Side Effects 903 Hoodia Side Effects 904 Hoodia Side Effects 905 Hoodia Side Effects 906 Hoodia Side Effects 907 Hoodia Side Effects 908 Hoodia Side Effects 909 Hoodia Side Effects 910 Hoodia Side Effects 911 Hoodia Side Effects 912 Hoodia Side Effects 913 Hoodia Side Effects 914 Hoodia Side Effects 915 Hoodia Side Effects 916 Hoodia Side Effects 917 Hoodia Side Effects 918 Hoodia Side Effects 919 Hoodia Side Effects 920 Hoodia Side Effects 921 Hoodia Side Effects 922 Hoodia Side Effects 923 Hoodia Side Effects 924 Hoodia Side Effects 925 Hoodia Side Effects 926 Hoodia Side Effects 927 Hoodia Side Effects 928 Hoodia Side Effects 929
 

Post a Comment

Older Posts
Newer Posts
Home