Thursday, November 10, 2005

Next Time, Start With the People

Guest Blogger

Heather Gerken

Christopher Elmendorf

Tuesday’s defeat of redistricting ballot initiatives in California and Ohio was a wake-up call for reformers, who are pressing a nationwide campaign to strip politicians of the power to draw electoral districts. California's Proposition 77, which would have vested line-drawing responsibilities in an independent commission composed of three retired judges, was rejected by six out of ten voters. Ohio's Issue 4 similarly lost by a significant margin. Yet polls show that large majorities of Republicans and Democrats agree that it is a bad idea for the legislature and the governor to make decisions about redistricting. What’s going on?

“Independence” sounds great in the abstract, but voters are well aware that purportedly neutral reforms may stack the deck against one side. The devil’s in the details, and the details can be fiendishly difficult for overburdened voters to figure out. As a result, people often vote based on simple cues, like who’s pushing for enactment. Democrats in California saw that Prop. 77’s most ardent advocate was Governor Schwarzenegger and voted no, much as Republican voters in Ohio rejected the nonpartisan redistricting mechanism designed by "Reform Ohio Now," a group whose name never appeared in press without the obligatory qualifier, “a coalition of unions and Democratic leaning groups.” Ironically, reformers who diagnosed redistricting as infected by politics and set out to cure it found themselves accused of being carriers of the same disease. This accusation proved deadly.

Yet reformers need to play politics if they’re to have a realistic chance of winning. It’s through the campaigning of interest groups and politicians that voters learn about proposed reforms and obtain the cues they need to decide how to vote. Moreover, political give-and-take plays an important role in ensuring a sensible and viable proposal in the first place. California reformers did too little politicking before putting Prop. 77 on the ballot. Two months ago they paid the price: groups representing Latinos and Asian Americans announced their opposition to the initiative, arguing that a redistricting commission composed of three retired judges could not reflect California’s diversity, and criticizing Prop. 77’s failure to include “respect for communities of interest” on the list of districting criteria. Had reformers solicited input from these groups before the initiative’s language was set in stone, a compromise could have been reached.

Is there a way for reformers to play politics as they must, while warding off the accusation of political infection? We would suggest taking a page from the playbook of our neighbors to the North. First in British Columbia and now in Ontario, basic electoral reform problems are being put to citizens’ assemblies, groups consisting of over a hundred randomly selected citizens who hear out competing presentations from experts and the concerns of interest groups and fellow citizens. If the citizens’ assembly reaches agreement on a proposed reform, it is submitted to the electorate for a referendum vote.

The citizens’ assembly represents an elegant solution to the dilemma of electoral reform. The assembly’s blessing insulates champions of reform from the charge that they’re playing politics with the ground rules of democracy -- precisely the charges levied in California and Ohio. Such accusations simply aren’t credible once the assembly -- ­the voice of the people, in microcosm­ -- has carefully considered the alternatives and recommended a course of action. Also important is that the assembly’s decision-making process accommodates give and take, enabling compromises to be hashed out and oversights corrected before a proposal reaches the ballot. Finally, the backing of the citizens' assembly could provide a useful cue for voters -- the democratic version of the Good Housekeeping Seal of Approval. In short, the citizens’ assembly offers a kind of political inoculation for reformers’ ideas. It introduces a little bit of politics into the reform process, while guarding against its worst excesses.

The strengths of the citizens’ assembly are vividly apparent when electoral reform is on the table, but this model for direct democracy might well prove salutary in many other settings. Consider California's experience with direct democracy. Ballot initiatives were supposed to provide an outlet for popular lawmaking, but today most Californians believe that special interests have wrested control of the initiative process. A California Citizens’ Assembly would make it possible for average people to regain some measure of influence over what appears on the ballot, while its “blessing” would give voters a good reason to vote in favor of a given proposal. And for politicians who profess to speak for the people themselves, what could be better than to serve as the Assembly’s mouthpiece?


Nice post.

That said, you should have stayed well away from suggesting 77's drafters merely "failed to include" respect or other criteria. A quick skim of the law should have been all it took: that monstrosity was not written by a reformer, it was written by a coldblooded right-wing apparatchik.

The sections at which to look are 2f and 2g, which manadate the contiguity of counties and cities, and compactnes, respectively. In California, as in all of the rest of North America, conservative voters are a slim majority in most geographical areas, and liberal voters are supermajorities in urban cores. The result of 2f and 2g would have been to enshrine a conservative gerrymander in the state constitution.

The sort of person who writes that -- and who, very specifically, places county contiguity foremost (calling Los Angeles, San Francisco, and Alameda, y'all) -- has zero interest in reform. That person is interested in power for him and his.

I guarantee that if the story of the drafting of Prop 77 is ever told, you'll feel slightly abashed you chose it, and not R-O-N, as your hypothetical.

I would have voted for real redistricting in California. Instead, I found 77 to be *worse* than the current gerrymander, and that's saying a lot.

Ugh, ptui. And you seem so smart. What were you kids thinking?

the story of the drafting of Prop 77 is ever told, you'll feel slightly abashed you chose it, and not R-O-N, as your hypothetical.Buy Dissertation | Buy Essay | Buy Research Paper

thanks for sharing great post, i really appreciate it.
Buy Term Paper | Buy Thesis

looks quite a great post, it's having good information for research analysis. great job

Buy Research Papers

Whenever i see the post like your's i feel that there are still helpful people who share information for the help of others, it must be helpful for other's. thanx and good job.

Buy Dissertations Online

Thanks for sharing

buy dissertations | essays

Your blog is really helps for my search and amazingly it was on my searching criteria.. Thanks a lot..
Buy Dissertation Online

It is excellent toward be real examine and who besides resolve study it he spirit absolutely obtain several supplementary.
Dissertation proposal template

Wholesale Galaxy Leggings,Cheap Galaxy Printed Leggings,Fast Shipping Worldwide.You Can Buy Various High Quality Wholesale Galaxy Leggings Products from China.
galaxy leggings
Wholesale galaxy leggings
cheap galaxy leggings

Its a great pleasure reading your post.Its full of information I am looking for and I love to post a comment that "The content of your post is awesome" Great work Judi Online

After read a couple of the articles on your website these few days, and I truly like your style of blogging. I tag it to my favorites internet site list and will be checking back soon. Please check out my web site also and let me know what you think. Sbobet Casino

I usually saw blogger put link in comment. I want to do the same thing, but i don't know how. from your article now i am understand.foto artis indonesia
foto seksi artis


greath post, Thank you for presenting a wide variety of information that is very interesting to see in this artikle

karimun jawa
and mebel jepara
or furniture jepara
and tenun jepara

Jika anda sedang mencari referensi mengenai harga mesin terbaru tahun ini maka anda dapat langsung menyimak Read More berikut ini yang mana berisi informasi harga mesin terbaru dan terlengkap serta terupdate.Saat ini mencari pekerjaan cukup sulit, maka dari itu alangkah baiknya jika anda menjadi seorang wirausaha sendiri dan sebagai pemula saya anjurkan anda membaca peluang usaha modal kecil yang mana membutuhkan modal kecil namun dengan hasil yang besar dan sangat cocok untuk pemula.

jika anda ingin belajar memasak anda dapat langsung mengunjungi situs kami pada resepmembuat99 yang mana disana terdapat banyak informasi seputar resep, atau anda juga dapat mengklik langsung Resep Cara Membuat Garlic Bread Mudah dan Lezat yang mana berisi cara membuat sajian garlic bread yang enak dan lezat. Anda juga dapat membaca Resep Cara Membuat Kue Cokelat Tanpa Tepung yang mana berisi info resep kue cokelat lezat, atau membaca Resep Cara Membuat Telur Orak-Arik Menu Sarapan Menyehatkan yang dapat anda pratekkan di rumah, atau membuat sajian Resep Cara Membuat Sandwich Telur Mudah dan Menyehatkan yang dapat di jadikan sebagai bekal, atau membaca Resep Cara Membuat Telur Dadar Enak, Mudah dan Menyehatkan yang cocok di sajikan untuk makan malam, atau membuat hidangan lezat dengan cara membaca Resep Cara Membuat Roti Telur Mata Sapi Enak dan Sehat yang cocok untuk anak-anak sebagai bekal sekolah, atau membaca informasi Resep Cara Membuat Nasi Bungkus Telur Ala Blueband Enak Menyehatkan yang sangat enak dan lezat, atau membuat sajian istimewa Resep Cara Membuat Roti Telur Ceria Lezat Cukup 10 Menit Saja yang akan menceriakan hari-hari kita, atau membuat jajajan kue kering yakni Resep Cara Membuat Rice Crispies Drops Kue Kering Lebaran Enak yang dapat anda buat dengan mudah dan yang terakhir Resep Cara Membuat Nasi Goreng Beruang Tidur Lucu dan Lezat yang dapat anda buat sendiri karena cukup mudah membuatnya. Jika anda ingin belajar memasak, saya anjurkan untuk baca resep terlengkap atau anda langsung saja baca kumpulan resep indonesia yang mana kami menyediakan banyak sekali informasi resep terkini. Anda juga dapat klik info resep enak dan lezat atau langsung mengikuti url kami dengan cara klik resep masakan khas Indonesia yang mana telah tersedia resep lengkap.

Jika anda seorang ibu rumah tangga yang baru menikah dan ingin belajar memasak maka anda dapat mengunjungi portal resep kami pada situs resep-kuliner99 atau langsung saja membaca ulasan resep spesial dari kami yakni Resep Cara Membuat Garlic Bread Mudah dan Enak yang mana dapat bermanfaat bagi anda yang masih pemula dalam menyajikan makanan cepat saji. Selain resep di atas kami juga membagikan banyak ulasan resep seperti Resep Membuat Kue Cokelat Tanpa Tepung Cocok Untuk Pemula yang mudah membuatnya tanpa menggunakan tepung, atau membaca referensi Resep Telur Orak-Arik Menu Sarapan Lezat Hanya 10 Menit yang sederhana dan lezat, atau membaca referensi Resep Sandwich Telur Cara Membuat Makanan Spesial Untuk Sarapan dan Bekal yang enak sebagai sajian sarapan menyehatkan, atau membaca referensi Resep Spesial Telur Dadar Lauk Enak Siap di Santap 10 Menit Saja yang mudah membuatnya dari telur dengan rasa spesial, atau membaca referensi Resep Roti Mata Sapi Siap Santap 10 Menit Ala Bluebland yang lucu dengan mata sapi sangat cocok untuk anak anda, atau membaca referensi Resep Nasi Blueband Bungkus Telur Enak dan Mudah Membuatnya yang mudah membuatnya serta lezat, atau membaca referensi Resep Roti Telur Ceria Ala Bluebland Yang Enak dan Menyehatkan yang lucu dengan bentuk ceria sangat cocok untuk sarapan anda, atau membaca referensi Resep Rice Crispies Drops Kue Lebaran Enak dan Mudah Membuatnya yang mudah membuatnya sebagai sajian lebaran bersama keluarga dan untuk yang terakhir kami juga memiliki Resep Nasi Goreng Beruang Tidur Ala Blueband Lucu dan Enak yang lucu dan imut dan mudah membuatnya sangat cocok sebagai bekal sekolah. Anda juga bisa baca artikel resep tradisional atau langsung mengunjungi baca artikel cara membuat makanan lezat yang mana disana terdapap resep lengkap. Anda juga dapat melihat resep membuat makanan super lezat atau ikuti saja linkresep membuat sajian enak yang mana menyediakan banyak info resep. Yang terakhir anda bisa read more info resep terbaru atau membaca baca selengkapnya resep asli Indonesia yang mana telah terdapat info resep kuliner terlengkap.

Very awesome post , i am really impressed with it a lot
When I first visited your blog, I liked the concept of your blog posts. It is very well portrayed as well as depicted

Arts de la table
recette tiramisu
gateau aux pommes
creme patissiere
creme anglaise
recette chantilly
recette gaufre
recette galette des rois
pate a crepe
recette crepe


Anda sedang mencari peluang usaha sampingan untuk tambahan penghasilan maka silahkan kunjungi PeluangUsahaSampingan99 yang mengulas secara lengkap informasi peluang usaha terbaru untuk anda. Baca disini Peluang bisnis rumahan modal kecil sekarang juga. Kemudian lihat juga artikel Peluang usaha rumahan sampingan yang menginspirasi. Setelah itu Peluang usaha sampingan karyawan sangat sayang untuk dilewatkan. Karena ada Peluang usaha pelajar mahasiswa yang sangat kami rekomendasikan. Selain itu baca dulu Tips usaha ternak bebek jika anda tertarik dengan usaha peternakan. Atau jika tidak Peluang usaha sampingan ibu rumah tangga mungkin bisa menjadi ide anda. Berikutnya ada Peluang usaha rumahan makanan beku yang masih sangat potensial. Lihat juga Peluang usaha modal kecil menguntungkan jika anda memiliki kendala dalam hal permodalan. Kemudian baca juga Ide peluang bisnis peternakan pilih salah satu yang menarik. Ingin usaha didesa lihat dulu Peluang usaha rumahan didesa bisa jadi alternatif. Pelaung usaha rumahan modal kecil baca selengkapnya disini. Kemudian baca disini aneka peluang usaha rumahan. Jangan lupa lihat artikel kami yang mengulas ide usaha untuk karyawan. Alasan kenapa anda harus kunjungi website kami karena ada inspirasi usaha untuk mahasiswa.

This comment has been removed by the author.

thanks bro,,

my web : Download lagu mp3 terbaru

Thank you for sharing in this article
I can learn a lot and could also be a reference
I hope to read the next your article updates

Alat Bantu Seksual Pria Wanita
Vigrx Plus
Obat Vimax Asli Canada
Galeri Alat Bantu Sex
Alat Bantu Sex
Vimax Asli
Alat Bantu Sex Pria
Obat Vimax
Alat Bantu Sex Wanita
Obat Kuat Viagra
Obat Pembesar Penis
Alat Bantu Pria
Vimax Pills Canada
Alat Bantu Wanita
Vimax Indonesia
Jual Vimax Pembesar Penis
Alat Bantu
Obat Pembesar Penis
Vigrx Plus
Blue Wizard


web tentang kunci motor

Nice article, thanks for the information. It's very complete information. I will bookmark for next reference
jaring futsal | jaring golf | jaring pengaman proyek |
jaring pengaman bangunan | jaring pengaman gedung

Hi all,"Next Time, Start With the People" this looks interesting and could be an inspiration

Perbedaan Vimax Asli dan Palsu - Obat Vimax Asli dan Palsu - Ciri Vimax Asli dan Palsu


Post a Comment

Older Posts
Newer Posts