Balkinization: Baggage Checks on NYC Subways -- Another Cosmetic Security Measure

Baggage Checks on NYC Subways -- Another Cosmetic Security Measure

Anonymous

The AP is reporting that police will begin random checking of people's bags on NYC subways:

Police will begin random searches of bags and packages carried by people entering city subways, officials announced Thursday after a new series of bomb attacks in London.

Passengers carrying bags will be selected at random before they pass through turnstiles, and those who refuse to be searched won't be allowed to ride, Police Commissioner Raymond Kelly said.

"We just live in a world where, sadly, these kinds of security measures are necessary," Mayor Michael Bloomberg said. "Are they intrusive? Yes, a little bit. But we are trying to find that right balance."

The announcement drew complaints from civil liberties advocates in a city where an estimated 4.5 million passengers ride the subway on an average weekday. The system has more than 468 stations — most with multiple entrances — and the flood of commuters hurrying in and out of stations during rush hour can be overwhelming.

Kelly stressed that officers posted at subway entrances would not engage in racial profiling, and that passengers are free to "turn around and leave." He also downplayed the possibility of bottlenecks at subway entrances.

That makes me feel better -- people are just free to leave, so the searching is fine. I'm dashing this post off quickly, so I won't explore the legality of this. But regardless of the legal issues, this seems to me to be a very silly policy. It is another big waste of money and time, as well as a needless invasion of civil liberties -- all for a cosmetic security benefit. There are 4.5 million passengers each day on the NYC subways. What good could a few random checks do? The odds of the police finding the terrorist with a bomb this way are about as good as the odds of being hit by lightning. I doubt it will have much of a deterrent effect either.

Also consider this from the story:

Kelly said passengers selected for searches will be approached by officers, who will ask them what they are carrying, and request them to open their bags. If an officer looking for explosives finds some other form of contraband, police said that person would be subject to arrest.

Does this mean that if the police find illegal drugs that they will arrest people? It isn't clear what categories of "contraband" are included in this statement.

A more effective strategy might be to use bomb sniffing dogs, as this would better prevent the police from conducting searches for drugs or things other than bombs. But even the use of dogs, with the sheer numbers of subway passengers, does not strike me as very effective either.

Posted 5:28 PM by Anonymous [link]

Comments:

Your great blog refers to online home based business which I found very interesting. Most home businesses seem to fail within their first year which is not surprising as many online home based business schemes are simply unworkable or offer too high expectations. Your perspective on the matter is very thought provoking - well done.

# posted by

The eye : 9:19 AM

I found a free best rated home based business resource blog/site that really helped me
get a handle on best rated home based business.

I thought your posters might find this best rated home based business resource useful.

best rated home based business

Check it out if you get time:-)

# posted by

Danny White : 3:48 AM

"I have just hit my fifties and I have established a very comfortable financial position. I am a financial consultant for a highly successful international brokerage house, but it has not always been that way.
I have experienced hard times, particularly when I was younger, and it was then that I developed the bedrock of my financial resources, The Winning Way which is on offer on this web site. Once that system took off the old adage of money makes money has never been more true. The instant cash flow gave me the opportunity to try out a trading system, 100% Profit In One Year which is also on offer here and this accelerated cash into my account like there was no tomorrow.

www.onlineuniversalwork.com HOME BASED WORK
"

# posted by

Anonymous : 12:14 PM

How To Make money with affiliate programs Today. Affiliate marketing is the easier and probably the most effective method to make money from the internet. It is basically, a kind of selling technique where potential buyers from your website are directed to the websites of sellers. For every click, the website owner gets a small commission.

www.onlineuniversalwork.com

# posted by

Anonymous : 1:52 AM

Hi you have create nice blog. thanks for your useful information.

Rabbit Hutches

# posted by

Top Collections in UK : 2:03 AM

If you can't be as best as you dreamed of,
Least be a good man in reality.
Agen Judi Online Terpercaya

# posted by

Unknown : 3:20 PM