Balkinization: It’s Not Only Security vs. Liberty, But Also Security vs. Security

It’s Not Only Security vs. Liberty, But Also Security vs. Security

Daniel Solove

The government spends millions of dollars in attempts to develop protections against terrorism in the name of national security. These measures often raise privacy and civil liberties concerns, and so the typical debate about a trade-off ensues. But in the larger scheme of things, terrorism is probably not the biggest national security risk we face. Historically, the numbers killed or injured by terrorism have been small; it is the possibility of a terrorist with nuclear or biological weapons that presents a very serious threat. I doubt that data mining and other government initiatives that are so threatening to civil liberties are really well-suited to addressing these threats. I have argued more in depth about why I believe the government is severely overreacting to terrorism as a security issue in a post on PrawfsBlawg.

The most devastating national security issue is, in my opinion, the possibility of a pandemic. But there is little attention to this issue. Sadly, it’s because all of the folks crying out to protect our security are so myopically focused on terrorism that they’re neglecting to think rationally about where the most likely risks are. It seems that countless world health experts are predicting an impending pandemic. We’re woefully unprepared, this Reuters article says:

Half a million Americans could die and more than 2 million could end up in the hospital with serious complications if an even moderately severe strain of a pandemic flu hits, a report predicted on Friday.

But the United States only has 965,256 staffed hospital beds, said the report from the Trust for America's Health.

The non-profit group's state-by-state analysis adds to a growing clamor of voices contending that the United States is not prepared for a large outbreak of disease, whether natural or brought on by war or terrorism. . . .

In an average year, influenza kills an estimated 36,000 Americans and puts 200,000 into the hospital.

A more serious strain strikes every few years and a so-called pandemic strain emerges once every 27 years, on average. The more virulent strains sweep around the world within months.

Pandemics hit in 1918 -- killing up to 40 million people globally -- 1957 and 1968. Health experts all say the world is overdue for another and fear the avian flu in Asia may be it.

The World Health Organization says an H5N1 avian flu pandemic could kill up to 7.4
million people globally, because people lack immunity to it. . . .

"The U.S. has not adequately planned for the disruption a flu
pandemic could cause to the economy, daily life, food and supply distributions,
or homeland security," the Trust's report reads.

"The U.S. lags in pandemic preparations compared to Great Britain and Canada based on an examination of leadership, vaccine development, vaccine and antiviral planning, health care system surge capacity planning, coordination between public and private sectors, and emergency communications planning." . . . .

When I read stories like this, I think of all the money wasted by TSA on developing airline passenger screening systems based on crunching through personal data or the Department of Defense’s expensive data mining research programs such as Total Information Awareness. Wasting money on programs where security benefits are highly questionable and where the civil liberties costs are significant is even more harmful because this is money not being spent on other measures that have more definite benefits.

So instead of talking about the usual trade-offs between security and civil liberties, perhaps we should begin talking about the trade-offs when we expend so many resources addressing one security issue while neglecting other security issues. Pandemics are national security issues too, but sadly “national security” appears to be co-opted as a synonym for “terrorism prevention.”

Posted 4:09 PM by Daniel Solove [link]

Comments:

With all due respect, we spend billions of dollars on health issues. We have HHS, NIH, CDC, the Surgeon General .... They have been there for decades.

# posted by

nk : 11:10 PM

Of course we spent alot of money on health, but take a look at the budget ... for the past two years I've been living in Central Asia and the CDC office here gets signficant funding from DOD to do bio/chemical threat reduction, rather than, let's say studying the avian flu. Right now, the key word for getting funding is "national security" and I agree with this post -- that has come to mean terrorism.

# posted by

jph : 6:15 AM

This blog is awesome! If you get a chance you may want to visit this genealogy software site, it's pretty awesome too!

# posted by

tweedledeetweedledum : 5:23 AM

Looking for wireless home security system info and perimiter cams I found our site. I agree totally!

# posted by

jon : 11:19 AM

We had been blogging trying to find how our world sees apria health care
. It has been a lifeline for us. Your site provides some of the best examples of this sort and we will bookmark yours. Another one we found was and appears to be related to yours is apria health care
site/blog. It pretty much covers apria health care
related stuff.

# posted by

Tom Naka : 4:14 AM

I found a lot of useful info about Data Mining on your blog - thank you. I also have a new Data Mining Tips blog - please click over and have a look

# posted by

Smartie : 4:05 PM

Private labelling and niche Blog strategy...

You may have a bunch of products with private label rights sitting on your desktop with no use.

I'll show you how to quickly turn the private label content into some nice Adsense and affiliate income.

What you'll need is:

1.) Content (taken care of)
2.) Blog (very simple)

A Blog is just a form of content management and publishing platform. You no doubt have heard about the benefits of using blogs for search engine traffic.

Google, Yahoo and MSN (the big 3) gobble up Blog content like a feeding frenzy.

Simply set up a WordPress Blog, add the private label content as posts on those blogs and watch as the search engine spiders take over your visitor stats and drive your rankings through the roof!

Then apply for the Adsense program through Google and place the ads right on your blogs.

Get more details on this method here:

http://www.ebooks-marketplace.com/elite.html

# posted by

Quit Smoking : 7:21 PM

Cool blog you have. I have a money laundering related site. Check it out if you get a chance. The URL is money laundering

# posted by

Swingin80 : 6:05 AM

Very cool blog you got! I just added you to my bookmarks!

I have a great article resource you might want to check out.

# posted by

Kingypoo : 12:58 AM

I saw something similar about bargain shopping

# posted by

brian : 3:56 PM

HI !

Just stoping by, You can allso visit my site about Link Popularity Building software, you can vist it at Link Popularity.
Thanks!

# posted by

miro : 7:10 AM

How would you like a quick and easy way to keep track of all your important information and activities maintenance . maintenance

# posted by

George : 10:28 PM

Dear Blog Owner,
so good to see a nice blog on personal development - a very fascinating subject. Thanks for taking the time to share this with us.

You can find mine on personal development here. Hope you will enjoy it as much as I did yours.
Regards
Barbara

# posted by

Barbara Hofmeister : 1:08 PM

Hey, you have a great blog here! I'm definitely going to bookmark you!

I have a really greatSEO site. It pretty much covers seo web design related stuff.

Come and check it out if you get time :-)

# posted by

Greg : 7:00 PM

Weird. I always thought the Rettop Method was the best for generating traffic. I am going to book mark this blog, nice topics discussed

By the way... I have a traffic accident site. It pretty much covers Traffic related stuff.

Come and check it out if you get time :-)

# posted by

Iravan : 9:11 PM

Want more clicks to your Adsense Ads on your Blog?

Then you have to check out my blog. I have found a FREE and Legitimate way that will increase your earnings.

Come Check us out. How to Boost Your AdSense Revenue

# posted by

Google Page Rank 6 : 2:48 AM

Hello, just visited your blog, it's informative. I also have a website related togoogle adsense software. So make sure you visit and hope it's useful.

# posted by

Gordon : 3:12 AM

I'm neither pro-choice nor pro-life. But I'm pro-free-life! Check out www.ProFreeLife.com.

# posted by

Pro Free Life : 3:32 AM